Skip to content
Published January 29, 2019

Episode 2 · January 29, 2019

Chamber Chat Podcast Episode 2 artwork

Prefer video? Watch Chamber Chat on YouTube →

Page Michel explains how the Washington County Chamber moved from fair-share dues to five benefit-based tiers, with careful planning, member choice and measurable retention gains.

About This Episode

Page Michel, president and CEO of the Washington County Chamber of Commerce in Brenham, Texas, explains its move from employee-count fair-share dues to five benefit-based membership tiers. She describes board and staff preparation, member focus groups, a benefits booklet and operational changes. She reports a 16% increase in dues income, no members lost during the launch year, and retention rising from 87% before the change to 94% in a later year.

What You'll Learn

  • Inventory all chamber benefits before designing tiers.
  • Educate staff and board and test packages with member focus groups.
  • Explain member choice through a clear benefits booklet.
  • Track dues income, member counts and retention; the chamber reported 16% dues growth and 94% retention.

About Page Michel

Page Michel is president and CEO of the Washington County Chamber of Commerce in Brenham, Texas. She has more than 25 years of experience in public relations, client engagement, event planning, government relations, and nonprofit association management, and has also served as shared president for the chamber, the Convention and Visitors Bureau, and the Brenham Economic Development Foundation.

Episode Chapters

00:14.798 — Guest introduction and Page Michel background

04:32.206 — Why Washington County Chamber moved to tiered dues

09:18.796 — Explaining the change with a membership booklet and ambassadors

11:16.886 — Mapping benefits into tiers and pricing packages

16:31.596 — Measuring success with dues, membership, and retention

21:27.692 — Five tiers plus a chamber friend level

23:06.978 — Examples of benefits at each tier

29:28.202 — Managing concerns and offering transition time

33:36.460 — Future of chambers and non-dues revenue

Resources Mentioned in This Episode

Membership packet

Membership levels booklet for the Washington County Chamber.

Explore Resource →

Hight Performance Group

Consultant resource mentioned in the episode as Kathy Height/Heidt.

Explore Resource →

Community Matters, Inc.

Mentioned in host background as the sales rep context for the chamber map.

Explore Resource →

An Idea Worth Borrowing

Move membership pricing from fair-share to benefit-based tiers

A chamber can transition successfully by inventorying every member benefit, packaging them into clear tiers, educating staff and board, and using focus groups and a booklet to explain choice instead of a dues increase.

• What services and benefits do we already provide that are not yet named or valued?
• Which benefits should be universal, and which should be reserved for higher tiers?
• How will we measure success through dues income, member growth, and retention?

Read the Full Transcript

Read the Full Transcript

This transcript has been lightly edited for readability and to correct obvious transcription errors while preserving the meaning of the original conversation.

Episode 2 — Membership models-"Fair Share" vs. "Tiered" with Page Michel
Clean Speaker-Labeled Transcript
Guest: Page Michel
Automated QA: Passed

00:00.842 Brandon Burton
This is the Chamber Chat Podcast, the show dedicated to chamber professionals to spark ideas and to get actionable tips and strategies to better serve your members and community.
00:14.798 Brandon Burton
Hello and welcome to the Chamber Chat Podcast. This is your host, Brandon Burton. Thank you for joining us today for our first interview episode on the show. Today we have Page Michel with us. Page is the president and CEO of the Washington County Chamber of Commerce in Brenham, Texas. Brenham is one of my favorite places because it is home to Bluebell Creameries, which makes the best ice cream. Page's background includes over twenty five years of experience in public rel public relations. Client engagement, event planning, government relations, and nonprofit association management. She is originally from the East Coast, raised in New York and Miami before becoming a Texan. In Texas, she's lived in Dallas and Houston before moving to the country in Central Texas. Page graduated from Western Carolina University in North Carolina and has her IOM certification from the U.S. Chamber Institute. She also completed several years of coursework with the University of Oklahoma Economic Development Institute. Her career began in Miami and Fort Lauderdale working for PR firms. In Texas, she began working exclusively with nonprofit organizations on their PR programs. For the past thirteen years, Page has served as shared president for the Washington County Chamber of Commerce, the Convention and Visitors Bureau, and the Brenham Economic Development Foundation. Page is an active volunteer with several state and local organizations, including the Texas Chamber of Commerce Executive Association, the Gulf Coast Chamber Executives, and the Rotary Club of Washington County. She and her husband Vince have two sons, one soon to be daughter in law, and one bonus son, an exchange student from Germany. Now I first met Page about ten years ago as I was the sales rep with Community Matters to handle. the Washington County Chamber map. Right away I was impressed with Brenham and Washington and the Washington County Chamber of Commerce, not only because of Bluebell, but because I could see the influence that the chamber had in their community. Just as a point of reference, usually as I sell ads for most chamber maps, we expect the sales process to take anywhere from three to five weeks. The last time I sold the map for the Washington County Chamber, we were sold out after just seven days.
02:40.43 Brandon Burton
To me that's a sign that things are going great at the chamber. I'm glad to have Page with us today to give us a little insight as to what goes on over there in Brenham, Texas. So Page, I know I just shared your bio, but can you say hello to the audience and also share maybe just one thing about you that would help the audience get to know you a little better? Maybe a hobby, interest, or interesting fact about yourself?
03:06.168 Page Michel
Sure, I'll be happy to, and thanks for having me on the show, Brandon. I hope that whoever's listening wants to get more information about operating the chamber. That's what we're here to talk about today. A little bit about me, aside from all the business information you read. I have always been occupied by things related to my kids. I know a lot of people are like that. I was a Sunday school teacher for eighteen straight years, you know, following them through the kids program into junior high and then a youth teacher and now my two sons are in college and daughter in law, but they are all performers, musicians and actors. So I, as a mom, am always traveling to their performances, which are always great and it's my joy. I go to lots of shows in Houston, Austin, San Antonio, but also some of the small towns in Texas. Smaller, like Conroe, Nathasota, Bryan College Station, San Marcus, Granbury. I really get to see these other towns and a little bit of their nightlife and I love doing that. And also rotary is a big part of my life outside of the office.
04:12.396 Brandon Burton
That is really interesting. I d I had no idea about your children being in the entertainment and that that that's neat. It gives you an opportunity to get around and have some good sources of entertainment and like you said, to see other parts of the states and there's other small towns and and how they operate. That's it.
04:29.9 Page Michel
Exactly.
04:32.206 Brandon Burton
So you're with us today to discuss some differences in membership models, specifically some differences between tiered dues and fair share of membership models. I understand that your chamber just recently went through a change in membership structure. Can you tell us how and when the Washington County Chamber decided that this is a move that you guys needed to make?
04:57.622 Page Michel
Yes. Well, I learned about the trend from about dues, you know, income in two thousand and ten when I started going to the U.S. Chamber Institute. that is where we all learn, you know, the latest trends in membership management and moving from what's known as the fair share model, which most chambers started in over a hundred years ago, where how many employees do you have translates to how much dues you pay. The trend is for different tiers, different levels. cost is different for different levels that would include different benefit packages. So that makes sense. That's how people choose their cell phone minute plans or their cable plans. People want choice. Well after I graduated from yeah, after I graduated from Institute, I sent our chambers membership manager and she went through her four years and she began hearing the same thing about the trend. And it was very important for us to have her complete buy-in because she would be, you know, over that with the membership and a transition completely changes the way you do business. So I don't know a lot of people that just want to go in and say, I want completely change the way we do business, but for the good of the organization we really learned it was necessary to stay relevant. And so in two thousand thirteen the American chamber executives published a white paper on revenue models for chambers. I shared that with our board. I finished Institute, our other staff went to the institute, so by two thousand fourteen, I think we were pretty much ready. At our board's annual planning retreat, we had a major discussion about this and we formed a tier dues review task force. We needed the whole board now to be on with us now that our staff was. We had to bring all of these volunteer leaders up to speed. And the task force remained in place through two thousand fourteen and two thousand fifteen and at the very same time we were planning for our chamber centennial. Our one hundredth anniversary was in two thousand seventeen and so we were thinking, gosh, do we do all that and change the way we do business in the same year? I mean, it was this a good thing to do we we wanted to make sure the message to the members was this is not a dues increase. You know, that's something that you have to be careful about.
07:22.586 Page Michel
the statistic is that generally when a chamber transitions to the tier dues model, they will see about a twenty percent increase in revenue. So we knew that, but that's not what this was about. But as things were going through 2016, we held five focus group sessions with members from all different industries and different sizes. We wanted to run this by them all. And the new membership model was formally launched. in two thousand seventeen, our centennial year. So that was last year. And it ended up being about eighteen months for the actual transition, preceded by about three years of planning.
08:02.686 Brandon Burton
three years of planning. So as you started to implement some of those changes first of all, was it would you say it was difficult to get your board on board with changing it to a tiered structure? Or did they jump on board right away?
08:21.312 Page Michel
I well anyone that's in a chamber, anyone that's listening knows we are getting educated ourselves in our field, but every year we get three or four or five or seven new bosses, so to speak, and we do have to educate them on things. So there was a process to get the board on board because they're coming from different fields and didn't really understand. But the beauty of it was nobody was opposed to it. Everybody gets it. From the get go, you're giving members choice. There is no downside that. There is no downside to that, right? But how do you actually then flip your chamber to deliver that? That's where the work comes in.
09:05.47 Brandon Burton
So that that was kinda leading to my next question is how were you able to communicate to the your chamber membership that this was not a dues increase, but rather offering more services?
09:18.796 Page Michel
Well, beyond these five focus groups where we brought people in, we didn't really do any messaging about new changes coming. So that that was not a message going out. What we did instead was we created a really nice membership levels booklet that they could read. And we educated our ambassador volunteers whom we called the Washington County Blue Blazers, and we gave them this booklet that they could show to new businesses that really spoke their language. it clearly outlines what benefits are available at each level. You know, just like I said, it's like selecting your cable TV package or your cell phone service package. And I think prior to that it was difficult for a staff member or a blue blazer to go into a new business who's a restaurant or some kind of shop and say, How many members how many employees do you have? Here's what you need to pay to join this in quote club. They did not get what a chamber was. They weren't familiar. But now they could come around and say, here's a list of marketing benefits and credibility and things you could get by joining the chamber and everybody understood it. So the messaging went very well. I think that everything went smoothly and successful. It just makes sense to people. And we knew there would be a a positive change. But like I'm mentioning and we can talk more about this, it's actually the work inside the chamber. to completely transition that that takes a lot of time and planning. Because everything from in your operations, from how you invoice people and you know, all the levels, everything has to change.
11:01.302 Brandon Burton
Yeah, so tell me more about that with the as far as having the different levels, how are you able to keep track of who's at what level and what membership benefits they're taking advantage of and just can you expand a little bit more on that?
11:16.886 Page Michel
Yes. And I also want to mention to whoever's listening, I think a lot of chambers have already made this transition. I know that in the years two thousand fourteen and fifteen we studied a lot of our nearby chambers. We got their booklets and looked at but there are still many chambers that haven't done this. So the very first thing you have to do, you actually have to put on paper everything you do, all your benefits. And you think you may have that, we thought we did, but the more we studied other chambers booklets, we saw, there's so many things we do that we just don't even put into words. And so we hired a consultant to help us through the process. we selected Kathy Height as our consultant. A lot of people know her, and she's a teacher at Institute. She's helped a lot of chambers through the same transition. So she brought a lot of lessons learned. to our process. And once we got down on paper everything that we do, we were able to put them in different buckets, so to speak, and you know, the from the highest bucket down to the basic level. Once you do that, we had to figure out different pricing for the packages. And then we had to figure out which state at different levels. That was what a lot of the discussion was in the focus groups. What you know got people to choose a higher level, what needed the Yeah, yeah, basic that everyone got. And that was really the most difficult part of the process. There's so many things a chamber, in quote, just does. It's not until you actually see it in writing that you realize how much value you have, like just displaying brochures in your lobby. If you have five hundred or a thousand people through your office, that's a huge value. the value of the clock display in their business, you know, if it's attractive, that's that's a real value to them for their credibility. They're being eligible to be on committees and task forces. Wow. You know, that's not available to non members. just they're receiving our weekly emails to stay informed on the community. We've got a notary free, you know, on premises. There's so many things that we do that we hadn't thought to put in writing and and put in the different levels. So that was a lot of the work for us. Once we've got everyone on board is get it getting everything on paper.
13:38.042 Brandon Burton
So those are some great points. besides some of the obvious thoughts that come to mind, what are some of the the pros and cons to the two models? I know I mean with the pros you're able to choose your services, you know, like you you mentioned, like a a cell phone plan where you can pick and choose what you want. where the fair share it was just strictly on how many employees you have. So and that part seems pretty obvious to me, but what are some of the other pros and cons between the two different models.
14:09.57 Page Michel
Well, honestly, I can't think of any cons to move your chamber from the fair share method to the tiered dues process. I think that and this is funny, we hear this from some of our institute teachers. If you're asking the business every year how many employees they have and they're gonna get a bill in a way, you're asking them to lie to you once a year. Twenty five or below it's one price and twenty six to fifty another price. Hmm, what do you think they're gonna say if they've got you know, twenty six people. I mean it's kinda funny, but it's really
14:40.206 Brandon Burton
They'll either have res resentment towards you or they'll lie to you or maybe a little bit of both, right?
14:45.214 Page Michel
Right. Right. And so really just don't need to go through that. And nobody really understands anymore why if they have twelve employees or twenty seven it would make a difference in what they pay to the chamber. So rather telling a business here are things we can do for you to help you stand out from other businesses, to give you a competitive edge, which grouping of services do you want this year? That makes total sense to them. So that's a pro. And we knew that When we were talking to the other chambers around the state and seeing their lists of different tiers and benefits, we saw we really learned from each other. And we we say when we go to our state meetings and regional meetings and we learn from each other's experiences, we don't have to reinvent the wheel. It's something chambers are great at doing. We get together and we share and we call it R and D for rip off and duplicate.
15:41.838 Brandon Burton
Yeah. Yeah.
15:45.922 Page Michel
We learn from each other and we're happy to share.
15:49.358 Brandon Burton
Well and that's kind of the the point of this show also, of this podcast, is to rip off and duplicate, really. You know, what what's working well for a chamber and and take some of those tips and strategies and implement it into your own and you know, see the benefits that come from that. so what like you you had mentioned, you don't really see any cons to switching to the fair share I'm sorry, to the tiered model. Why would a chamber be hesitant to make the change. Would it you think it would just be out of fear of people not renewing or not understanding the the communication of it all? Why would somebody chamber hang on to it?
16:31.596 Page Michel
Yes, all of those comfort zone. That's what I think. I think that if you're doing business one way and things are fine, why would you want to change everything? It is hard. But the reason is for future relevance to stay relevant in the new millennium. I mean, to be relevant in the coming years and there's a lot of good information about this online, both through A C C E and other sources. You just you have to do this to stay relevant. That's my personal feeling. And we wanted to know if we made this change, how would we know we were successful? What would that look like to the members? What would that look like to us? And there's basically three key ways to measure your success. First is your total dues income. You can measure from year to year how much you make in your dues. Number two is how many members do you have and how many new members did you gain that year? And the third key way to measure a chamber's success is your retention rate. How many members are you keeping year over year? And I am happy to say I just crunched some numbers before the show. Our chambers tran since our chambers transition, we experienced over sixteen percent increase in dues income. So that feels very good to us. It's a very yeah positive sign. Like I said, we didn't do this for a dues increase, but it's kind of icing on the cake, right?
17:59.31 Brandon Burton
Well I and I would imagine you know, some chamber or some members may be paying less in dues, but you'd probably have more members, which would come to your your second point there. if you have more members paying a little less, but they're getting services that match what they're paying for their membership, in the end, it sounds like everybody wins. Is that what you saw with the number of members increasing?
18:22.974 Page Michel
Right. And you just hit the nail on the head with one of the key fears. some of the board members are afraid. You know, if you give everyone th these packages, what if some of our top members choose the lowest package? Well, you know what? If that's what they think of what they get from the chamber, that's so be it. That is our job is to work hard to give benefits that want to move everyone up to the higher tiers. But really need to give the member that choice. And The statistics told us, our consultant told us, you know, like I said before, typically chambers see about a twenty percent increase, and so you have to move forward with it. And so we did. We saw a sixteen percent increase, which has been great. Then in our number of new members, which we track every year, we had about the same number of new members in the year of our after our transition as the prior year. And by the way, I hadn't told you yet about our chamber. We have we are a countywide chamber, the Washington County Chamber is. We've got three or four small towns in our county and then Brenham is the county seat. We have eight hundred and thirty members, which is a really good size for a rural chamber. We see anywhere from sixty to seventy to eighty new members a year. And the year we launched our transition, we had seventy-seven new members, and then last year we had sixty-six new members. Now we don't do a membership drive. at all during the year. Some chambers do that and they'll gain a couple hundred members at a time. We are measuring our retention rate. but the key thing I wanted to say is in twenty seventeen, our transition year, we didn't lose a single member.
20:04.852 Brandon Burton
Not one. Really? That is impressive.
20:08.875 Page Michel
Yes, I know.
20:11.118 Brandon Burton
So for any any chamber out there that's scared about the transition Yeah. Here here's here's some proof that you that you guys did not lose any members at that transition. That's amazing.
20:22.828 Page Michel
It's amazing. And then here's the final membership measurement, the retention rate. So we had been measuring measuring that in the years before the transition, our chamber was already at a very high retention rate of eighty seven percent. And they tell us at Institute that for a membership organization, anything over eighty percent is a very good retention rate. So we were at eighty seven, which we were very happy about. And then the subsequent years to that we hit ninety percent and we were thrilled. The last Yeah, last year after the transition, we measured the retention rate ninety four percent.
21:00.064 Brandon Burton
Wow. That is amazing. It is amazing. It's almost unheard of. Yeah.
21:05.194 Page Michel
No, and that's so the businesses that we lose during the year are for, you know, they're moving or closing their doors, which is always sad, but that's inevitable. So we're very happy overall with the suc success of this transition.
21:19.502 Brandon Burton
That is awesome. So in the end, how many how many tiers did you guys end up offering as you switched to the tier model?
21:27.692 Page Michel
That is great question. We have five tiers and anyone that's interested can go to our chamber website and take a look at our booklet. It's a PDF, you know, stored on our website under Join This Chamber. And our website is www.brenhamtexas dot com. Brenham, Texas all spelled out dot com. And so we had and I should mention for those looking into this, we had a a quasi tiered basis for ten years before the transition. early on we knew and we heard, you know, at at conferences about tiers. So we had the fair share method, but optionally we had two high tiers, the presidential level and a chairman circle level. And some of our largest businesses chose those straight away. Some banks, you know, Bluebell Creameries, Germany Insurance are great, large businesses in Brenham. But the other eight hundred and you know, twenty members were still just fair share methods. So we had to at the start. And after everything was said and done, we have a basic level, we have a business builder level, a business investor level, and then the presidential level and the chairman circle. So we have five levels. Plus, we also identified a separate little level called the chamber friend. This is for retired individuals or people who might just want to pay a small amount just to stay involved and get our emails.
22:52.554 Brandon Burton
Okay. That makes sense. So can you give us a few examples maybe of benefits offered at the different tier levels? Maybe at each tier just, you know, two or three benefits that your members would be able to see?
23:06.978 Page Michel
Yeah. And some of the most important mem member benefits are always tax name out in the world. Okay, they want business referrals. That makes sense. So getting their name into the chamber printed directory, very important. But online, making sure that they're found online on a very credible source, which is a chamber website, that starts at the basic level. We believe in that. Everyone's going to get that. Plus a plaque to display, getting to put their brochures in the lobby. those are things that we feel all members should get. Then additionally, at the basic level, everyone, you know, gets into free into networking events or some have ticketed prices, and can serve on committees and be ambassadors. When you move to the next level, you think what's gonna get someone to invest a little bit more? There are growing businesses that have some unique needs, they want to get their name out there, and you know what? They may only have one or two employees. They may be a mom and pop shop but they want more. And so the Fair Share method would never allow that. But we have a level where they get additional listings on in the directory and online, additional ways for people to find them. They are able to display additional materials. They get featured in our weekly e blasts and business spotlights, things like that. They can also get our membership on labels that they can do mailings with them. They get tuition discounts on our leadership program. So you know you see there's some enhanced benefits just by moving up one level. And then in our next level Yeah, the business investor is a level where these are firms of all sizes who probably want more visibility, particularly online. And so we have a lot of good benefits from that. Plus we do a social media focus package. We will do videos at their business, share them online, they can reshare them. And while a business could do that for themselves, having a third party credible source do it for you throws you way, way up in the search results online. So that's something that we added. Then our presidential Yeah. Our presidential and chairman circle levels have a lot of prestigious things. They get invited to exclusive events with elected officials and things like that and plaques and recognition and all of our events.
25:30.156 Page Michel
And like I said, people can look that up on our website.
25:35.338 Brandon Burton
Okay. Yeah, and we'll we'll share that that PDF that you had mentioned in the show notes for this episode. so people can check that out and just click directly from the link there. In in coming up with the different benefits for the different tiers, did you find I know earlier you had mentioned that you had to start off just by really writing down, listing every service that your chamber offers. Did you find as you created the tiered package that you were creating new services, new benefits that you could offer? And if you did, how were you able to keep those benefits scalable?
26:13.72 Page Michel
Great questions. And yes and yes. So that was a big part of our transition, as I said before, was just getting everything down on paper with our staff, with our volunteers and our focus groups, and then putting them in the different buckets, you know, for the different levels. And then the thought to get people to go to the next levels, what would it be? And we did create a few new things, like the social media focus package and like having members in the different e blasts. And so some levels get that benefit once a year, the next level gets it every six months, the higher level gets it every quarter. So that's how we made it scalable.
26:52.248 Brandon Burton
That's great. I know I'd I'd seen some about you know, some chambers will maybe offer some consulting services. You have some time with the CPA or a marketing consultant. is that anything you guys considered or did you just strictly want to stick with what the chamber can offer?
27:12.15 Page Michel
Well, you know what? We do that for every member, starting at the basic level. When they join, we give them a lot of one on one attention and they can and do visit with all of our staff. We have what we call chamber one one a few times a year where they just come in and can have hands-on assistance and we will and we do we even sit down with members at their place of business, in front of their computers and help them with their social media. That's really why we're in the ninety percent retention rate is and you know, we're a smaller community, but we are able to get out there and do that with every member.
27:49.718 Brandon Burton
Yeah. And and like you mentioned, you being a smaller community, you guys have that advantage and it really really shows that the retention numbers and I'd encourage any of the smaller say smaller, but you know, eight hundred members or so to try to take advantage of, you know, having that personal contact with your members and help them with their marketing strategies and and things like that where you can. I know, you know, another option, maybe, you know, for a larger chamber is You know, if you have a chamber member that offers marketing consultation, maybe they would come on board and be part of that tiered package where they could offer their services at a discount, but maybe see, you know, new customers coming their way just by having that interaction with more businesses, you know, that join at that certain membership tier. that's just a a thought for some some larger chambers.
28:42.954 Page Michel
It is. And we do see that when we got booklets from other chambers. I mean, we probably looked at thirty. We for like two years were collecting from so many chambers of all different sizes. And some of them are able to do the mentoring like you know what you mentioned, some business to business discounts. There are great ideas out there. So I de I definitely stress working with a consultant and or just taking the time to look at what all other chambers are doing.
29:12.204 Brandon Burton
Right. So I I think my next question, I think you kinda answered earlier, when you talked about the the membership numbers and retention rates, but during this transition, did you have anybody that was unhappy?
29:28.202 Page Michel
Really we didn't. I know that there was one member who called and was just not happy about the change. You know, some people don't like change, but change is inevitable. However, you know, that so one thing that we implemented and our board agreed is we had two years that someone could stay at the fair share method. So two full cycles. They could still choose the old way before they had to make a chance. So we gave people time, time to you know, be become more informed and to choose their level.
30:01.902 Brandon Burton
That's great idea. I'm glad you shared that because a lot of people do kind of get in that mindset that no matter how good the offer is, they just don't want to change. You know, things have been good and why why fix something that isn't broken, right? So to give them that that time period to evaluate and maybe see what some of the other members are getting with the the new model will will help them bring them on board, you know, over that time period. what was what was the most difficult part during the transition? Was it the planning process? Was it implementing? Is it following through at the different tier levels? What would you say is the most difficult part?
30:39.468 Page Michel
Well, there were different phases and it was difficult throughout. It was moving everyone out of their comfort zone. So from my seat as the chamber president, getting each of the staff, you know, to embrace this and we we took our time, we sent our two additional managers through Institute so that they could embrace it, then moving our board and our own volunteers through it and then deciding with the board if we wanted to really invest in ourself and hire a consultant and we agreed that we did want that. Well then getting everything down on paper was the next and really the most difficult part of the process. And I can't stress that enough that I think the chambers should take the time and really identify all of those nuances, those things that you do. There's a value to that. And in our booklet, at the end of each of these benefits, we have in principles approximately what we value that as. you know, something is just worth fifty dollars, some things are worth two hundred dollars, five hundred dollars, a thousand dollars. I mean what if you had a ribbon cutting and had your photo and information about your new business in the local radio and newspaper, what would a business pay for that exposure, right? We need to think that way. What we're offering is this huge value. So taking the time with that and seeing what other chambers listed and we're like, yeah, we do that too, that was the most difficult part because it took eighteen months. But it was worth it.
32:06.178 Brandon Burton
Wow. So for the chamber folks that are listening, what direction would you give them to know when the time might be right for their chamber to make a change or to at least evaluate making a change in membership models?
32:19.404 Page Michel
Well, if there are chambers out there that haven't already done this or haven't fully done it, some of us have the mixed, you know, versions of it. I can't recommend more highly to get involved with your state and regional association. There are state chambers across the nation, they all have state conferences, many of us also have regional and share with your peers. I mean, just like they say in tennis, you want to play with a better player. So look at those chambers that you admire. Get their list of how they're doing their membership and study that, study that a lot. And then the Chamber U.S. Chamber Institute. We learn so much from those instructors. So I think just really getting educated is my number one tip.
33:01.452 Brandon Burton
I think that's sound advice. Just it's being stay staying up with the times, educating yourself and just keeping a pulse on your your chamber and the community and just try to really find when that time is right. Now as we as we kind of wrap things up here, I wanted to ask, as we all try to prepare for the future, kind of look at our our magic ball and look into the future. What do you see the future of chambers looking like and what changes do you anticipate or hope to see?
33:36.46 Page Michel
That is a great question. and that's something that we ask ourselves all the time. Certainly I feel like that's our job as chamber presidents to be looking ahead. Six months down the road, a year down the road, and then three and five years down the road. there is a great resource through the American Chamber of Commerce Executives, the Chamber Horizon Initiative, where they have identified eight key factors that we need to be looking at, and I would say every chamber exec needs to take a deep dive on that. You can find that online even if you're not yet a member of ACCE. But we also know that every chamber is different. Okay? We we like to say if you've seen one chamber, you've seen one chamber. Okay? They are not all the same. Yeah. And so ours, we're in a slightly smaller area. We're gonna be different from one of the big metro area chambers. But what I see the future of for our smaller area chamber is is to become like a marketing agency. And I say that over and over to our board and to the members. We are your local community marketing agency. So if we want we want to help small businesses have that competitive edge, how to stand out with their messaging in a very crowded field. And we can and we do do that. So they get that. Number two, I would say from an operational standpoint for the future, The chambers need to look at where they get their income from. If it can't all be some due, no matter how good your tiers are. And the guiding rule is about fifty fifty, dues income to non dues income. So what are those things your chamber is gonna do to have income that's not from due? Well many chambers do fundraisers like golf tournaments or taste of the town or things like that. And then we have ways that our big events get sponsored. There are many other ways to achieve nondues revenue and that's really what we are all sharing right now. We're learning from each other. What else are you doing besides, you know, just so that's the future. That's like the short term future. What are the things that a chamber can do with our limited staff and resources for non dues income?
35:53.72 Brandon Burton
That's great. Great advice to kind of be looking down the road and try to see what what you can do at your chamber to become that marketing agency. Be able to to help those members get their name out to the community and and really just drive more business to them. And in essence that's what a chamber's always been. But I think with times changing and social media and things digital and there's so many more options now for marketing and businesses are all different. you know, to as to what would be the best strategy for them. So I think that's a great point to a as a chamber to really know, you know, what you have to offer and and the direction you can point your members to. Thank you for that.
36:35.874 Page Michel
And I do want to tell you, Brandon, that we appreciate so much what you do with our project, with our community map, and that is a great source of non dues revenue and it's something that those members really value. So I also want to tell Chamber execs to reach out and bring those resources into your chamber if you're not already doing that.
36:55.79 Brandon Burton
Sure, I'd I I I'll just add a little bit to that. I you know I've heard some chambers, you know, hesitant to do an app or directory of some sort like that because they don't want to burden their members, you know, with with another cost. And you know, the the way we look at things is you know, it's advertising. And if it's something if it's a strategy that can work for them to drive more business to them, then it can't be looked at as an added cost to them, but it's a benefit that can add more business to them. So thank you for for mentioning that.
37:29.315 Page Michel
Yes.
37:31.29 Brandon Burton
well Page, I appreciate you, you know, coming on the show with us and sharing some of your insight and experience with this transition. if any of the listeners needed to get in contact with you or wanted more information about how you went through this transition, how can they get in contact with you?
37:51.31 Page Michel
Great. I'll give them two easy ways. First they can look for our website, which is our city name, city and state, Brenham Texas dot com B R E N H A T E X A S dot com and then I'll give them an easy email, they won't have to write down info at Brenham Texas dot com. So if they send that, we we will get that here and we will share with them all of our resources.
38:18.264 Brandon Burton
That's perfect. Thank you so much, Page. it's been a pleasure talking with you today. And I hope the listeners got a lot of value out of what you had to share. And for those that have not made the transition yet to a tiered model, I hope they can reevaluate maybe and I'm not trying to convince them one way or another, but maybe they can see the value of this and and maybe take a deeper dive into saying if this is something their chamber's ready to do. Okay. So you just Listen to my interview with Page Michel at the Washington County Chamber of Commerce. I hope you received some value out of this episode. If you have not changed membership models at this point, hopefully this episode gave you some compelling arguments why it might be something good to look into. And maybe you already have changed over to a tier dues membership. And if you have, maybe you got some ideas out of this of different levels of value that you can offer to different tier levels. Or just different ways to implement these tiered strategies. If you would like to access the show notes for this episode, they can be found at Chamberchatpodcast.com/slash episode two. And in the show notes for this week, we'll include the membership pamphlet for the Washington County Chamber of Commerce and the contact information for Kathy Heidt, who is the consultant who helped Page with her with the transition there at the Washington County Chamber of Commerce. Anyways, thanks for listening and we'll look forward to chatting with you next week.

Continue Exploring

Explore more Chamber Chat conversations related to this episode.

Episode 104: A Unique Membership Model with Tiffany Esposito →

Related topics: Membership, Member Retention, Non-Dues Revenue

Episode 121: Futureproofing Chambers with Boyd Stough →

Related topics: Membership, Member Retention, Chamber Operations

Keep Learning with Chamber Chat

Continue the conversation and explore more Chamber Chat resources.

Subscribe to Chamber Chat →
Get easy access to new episodes and updates.

Watch on YouTube →
Prefer video? Watch Chamber Chat on YouTube.

Join Chamber Chat Champions →
Connect with other chamber professionals.

Podcasting for Chambers →
Learn how your chamber can use a podcast strategically.

Monetize Your Podcast →
Explore ways to generate business value and revenue from your podcast.

Chamberpad logo

Discover Chamberpad
Stay connected with chamber news, ideas, resources, events, and industry updates from across the chamber world.