Skip to content

Category: Compensation

Executive & Board Relationships with Tony Vedda

Miles Burdine Chamber Chat Podcast promo image.

Below is an auto-generated transcription. Because this is auto-generated there are likely some grammatical errors but it is still a useful tool to search text within this podcast episode.

Feel free to join our Chamber Chat Champions Facebook Group to discuss this episode and to share your own experiences and tips with other Chamber Champions.

Brandon Burton (00:00.908)
Hello, Chamber Champions. Welcome to Chamber Chat Podcast. I’m your host, Brandon Burton, and here on the show, I introduce you to people and ideas to better help you serve your Chamber members and your community.

Our guest for this episode is Tony Vedda. Tony is the President and CEO of the North Texas LGBTQ Chamber of Commerce, where he has led the organization since 2007 as its first chief executive. With more than four decades of chamber leadership experience, Tony began his career as membership specialist for the greater Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce and later worked with the Metropolitan Chambers in Arizona and California.

He also served as the executive director of San Francisco’s Golden Gate Business Association, the nation’s first LGBT Chamber of Commerce, further solidifying his commitment to inclusive economic development and advocacy. Tony returned to the chamber to chamber leadership in 2005 as secretary for the newly formed North Texas LGBTQ chamber before being named president and CEO two years later.

a role that he continues to hold today. Under his leadership, the chamber has grown into a powerful voice for LGBTQ-owned businesses and inclusive economic growth across North Texas. Tony is an IOM graduate and he holds a prestigious certified chamber executive designation from ACCE as well, an honor earned by only 3 % of active chamber leaders nationwide and the only LGBT chamber leader to receive it.

Brandon Burton (01:57.102)
He also holds a certificate in diversity and inclusion from Cornell University. Tony is deeply engaged in professional leadership and advocacy. serves on the ACCE board of directors, chairs the ACCE certified chamber executive commission, and is a founding member of the Texas LGBTQ chambers of commerce, a statewide advocacy coalition.

He is also a respected speaker and faculty member of the US Chambers Institute for Organization Management. But Tony, I’m excited to have you with us today here on Chamber Chat podcast. I’d love to give you an opportunity to say hello to all the Chamber Champions who are out there listening. And if you would share something interesting about yourself so we can all get to know you.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (02:43.959)
Well, I’m really impressed with what you just read because I don’t know who that guy is, but I’d hire him in a heartbeat. He sounds perfect. Yeah, it’s always weird to hear those those introductions, but thank you, Brandon. Thank you for inviting me to be on today. Something interesting about me. I am the most uninteresting person in the world, I believe, but I’ve had a lot of

Brandon Burton (02:51.371)
That’s right, for anyone listening.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (03:13.641)
interesting jobs in my life. When I was very young, I worked in a computer assembly plant in Albuquerque, New Mexico, prior to working at the Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce. Shout out to Terry Cole, who is still the CEO at the Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce and was when I was just a little baby membership person.

Brandon Burton (03:26.795)
OK.

Brandon Burton (03:42.412)
Wow.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (03:43.671)
Anyhow, I ended up leaving Albuquerque to pursue a degree in music theater performance at Arizona State University, which has served me well in my chamber work. There’s a lot of acting and cap once and going on.

Brandon Burton (03:58.275)
I was gonna say, Tony is a great emcee for anyone who’s ever been at a conference, he’s emceed, he’s great.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (04:04.119)
I find myself often tap dancing in front of my board. No, not really there. I love my board. But yeah, and I’ve had a chance to live in great places. I lived in New York for a while. I lived in New Hampshire, not so great. Just kidding, New Hampshire’s fine. I performed at Hershey Park in Hershey, Pennsylvania, where it always smells like chocolate. Anyhow, I finally ended up here.

Brandon Burton (04:10.208)
Right?

Brandon Burton (04:26.444)
Very cool. Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (04:32.246)
my husband, who was not my husband at the time. We had been dating for two years in San Francisco and his job moved him back here. And as I like to say, I had just about gotten him the way I wanted him and wasn’t really wanting to start all over. So I moved with him and we’re still together. 30, 31 years later and we’re still together.

Brandon Burton (04:50.134)
I love it.

Brandon Burton (04:56.79)
It’s worked out. That’s great. I love it. Well, it’s fun getting those interesting histories and facts about people. If you would spend a couple of minutes and tell us about the North Texas LGBTQ Chamber just to help give us an idea of size, staff, scope of work you guys are involved with, budget, but also I think it’d be helpful to tap into some of the demographics of the LGBTQ community.

and how that plays into the larger economic impacts.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (05:28.407)
Yeah, sure, I’d love to. And I’m a little bit of a geek when it comes to number kind of things. So I’m always happy to talk about that. So our chamber, as you mentioned earlier, was started in 2005. There was a predecessor organization that began in 1996 or so, I believe, called the Stonewall Professional and Business Association, which was mostly networking. So the idea of creating a chamber

came along at the time Houston had a very active and very successful Chamber of Commerce. So their CEO came up and helped the founders of ours get things going. Interestingly enough, a few years later that chamber closed. But then a few years after that, I went to Houston and helped them restart a new chamber, which is having its 10th anniversary. they are doing great guns. mean theโ€ฆ

Brandon Burton (06:06.87)
Okay.

Brandon Burton (06:16.802)
Restart it, yeah.

I was going say, I thought they had one in Houston now. So yeah, that’s awesome.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (06:24.629)
the student has surpassed the teacher. So anyhow, so we are a dynamic staff of two who do the work of probably 12. Lisa Howe is my vice president of membership and programs, and I lean on her a lot. She also runs our leadership program through our foundation, which is a big job. We have just under

just under just over 400 members, let’s just say 400, 400 members in our chamber. estimate, again, we have to estimate on LGBT statistics mostly because we only know if somebody self identifies, but based on some trusted data, we estimate that they’re probably about,

Brandon Burton (06:56.909)
Okay.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (07:20.302)
3,000 to 3,500 LGBT owned businesses in Dallas County. So you can think that out further from that North Texas. So when you look at that, our penetration rate really, really is not very good. So I don’t know why I’m admitting it, but there you go. That’s right, there’s endless opportunities. I will say, you we’ve had a

Brandon Burton (07:27.522)
Wow.

Brandon Burton (07:38.958)
You got your work cut out for you, that’s all.

That’s right.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (07:49.098)
a lot more interest from small business members lately, which has been good because of the current political climate. A lot of our corporate partners, not a lot, a few, have felt the need to step back, which is disappointing, but understandable. So we’re okay. Let’s see. So for years, this great firm in D.C. called Whittick Communications would estimate the spending power of the LGBTQ community.

Brandon Burton (08:05.837)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (08:18.039)
Last time they did it, I think it was pre-COVID or just around then, and it was about a trillion dollars. So we take that information and we kind of extrapolate for us here. And in North Texas, that spending power is about 5.4 million. I’m sorry, billion. You know, my M’s and B’s. So 5.4 billion dollars. So that’s a pretty significant number.

Brandon Burton (08:30.793)
you

Brandon Burton (08:37.624)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (08:46.359)
And so that’s great when you’re looking at the consumer side of things and businesses itself to consumers. But because we are a chamber, we also look at GDP. So what are our businesses adding to the local economy? so I believe, hang on, I have to look at my note real quick. Yeah, so the information that we’ve garnered says about $4.4 billion.

A GDP is generated by the LGBTQ by LGBTQ businesses in the North Texas area, and it’s a metropolitan statistical area. know that kind of thing. So we are we are we are adding to the community and to the tax base in a big way.

Brandon Burton (09:26.318)
Wow.

Brandon Burton (09:33.799)
Absolutely. So it’s an interesting.

challenge, I guess, when, you know, individuals need to self identify and almost put themselves out there saying, Hey, I fit this demographic of a LGBTQ, you know, owned business to be able to find those 3000 to 3500. Um, so I, mean, I don’t, I don’t fault you at all for having 400 members because it’s got to be difficult to sift through.

all of that to try to find all these individuals and businesses.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (10:11.159)
And to be clear, we do not ask anyone to self identify. And so members of our chamber do self identify and many of them are allies who have varying reasons for being part of the chamber. But they support our mission and the work that we’re doing. And as long as they do that and of course pay their dues, we’re happy to include them in the chamber.

Brandon Burton (10:24.75)
Yeah.

Sure.

Brandon Burton (10:38.026)
Absolutely. So I guess the question I was getting at is, is there a way to try to find your way to those businesses? Because you’re not asking them to self-identify, but you want to be support for them and help them in their business. And how do you try to bridge that disconnect there?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (10:55.881)
Yeah, so you know, we just passed our 20th anniversary and we are still and I should not be proud of this. We are still probably the best kept secret in North Texas. It seems like weekly I hear some is that I didn’t know there is a gay chamber in North Texas, so. And I think that’s typical for most chambers. I think within certain communities you you assume there’s going to be a Dallas Chamber, Plano Chamber, etc.

Brandon Burton (11:07.694)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (11:23.255)
Sure.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (11:24.907)
But, you know, the LGBT community isn’t often thought of in those same terms. And like most chambers, we do not do a very good job telling our story. Most of the time, our story is somebody else’s. So a good example, this is from many years ago, so I think it’s safe to talk about now. So there was a hotel being built in Dallas that the city was very involved in. We were very supportive of the hotel.

Um, and then found out that the operator of the hotel, uh, didn’t even offer, uh, domestic partner benefits, which is kind of a minimal thing back then. Um, and so we were able to get in with them, have a good talk with them. Um, they, they of course had to offer those in California, except it was the law, but they didn’t hear, but they did. Uh, and then a few years later, the national chamber was coming here for its annual conference. And I reached out to the same folks and the.

Brandon Burton (12:04.364)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (12:23.745)
things had changed a little bit. And I said, okay, now we need to talk about marriage and recognizing same sex marriage and whatever. It was hardly a conversation. I mean, it was pretty quick. And so they absolutely agreed the following year at the beginning of the year, they changed their benefits to recognize LGBTQ marriages from any state. And at the time, Texas didn’t have same sex marriage. So those are things that the chamber did.

that except for me talking to you about it now, I think maybe one of your outside person knows because it’s not our story. It’s that business story of all the great things they’ve done, but it was done because of the work of the chamber. But, you know, we’re the background people.

Brandon Burton (13:04.942)
Sure.

Brandon Burton (13:13.548)
Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. Well, today we’re going to focus most of our conversation around the relationship between the executive and the board and you know the good, the bad and the ugly that comes with that. And we’ll dive into that as soon as we get back from this quick break.

App My Community creates mobile apps that allow you to engage directly with your community. Enhance chamber membership by providing a unique advertising and communication channel to residents and visitors. Not just a member directory, App My Community has the tools to be useful to residents on a daily basis. Learn more at appmycommunity.com/chamberchat.

Alright, Tony, we’re back. As I mentioned before the break today, we’re going to talk about the executive and board relationships and

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (13:34.295)
Very good.

Brandon Burton (13:43.265)
I know you have a perspective that you’ve seen throughout the industry of maybe tensions that rise between the executives and their board chairs or the board in general. Share with us some of the background that you’ve seen that’s led up to this topic for discussion today.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (14:01.291)
Yeah, if I go way back when I was at the Golden Gate Business Association in San Francisco, which was the early 90s, I was the only paid. Executive at an LGBT Chamber. There weren’t nearly as many of them, but I was the only one at the time which I thought was kind of odd. But what we saw then in in in the LGBT Chamber world organizations tended to kind of come and go.

Brandon Burton (14:22.2)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (14:30.575)
and or they’d be very active and very inactive and it had to do with their board leadership because they had no staff. There was no continuity between, you know, year over year and such. So that was something that I observed then that I probably didn’t really appreciate until I started working here. But I had been in and out of the chamber industry a number of times, a number of times I kept saying I was going to walk away.

When I moved to Texas, I said, that’s it, I’m done. No more chambers, no more nonprofits. Nonprofits are great, except for when they expect you to be nonprofit as well. And so I wanted to have a successful career and be able to retire one day. So I worked in banking for a while, which if any industry will make you dead inside, it’sโ€ฆ

Brandon Burton (15:10.53)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (15:16.18)
Yeah

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (15:25.111)
banking. But nonetheless, it was it was very educational. I enjoyed my time in banking. But this chamber came along. And I’ve been out of the industry a long, long time. I can can can spare a little volunteer time to help out. And the next thing you know, I was elected to the board, we became the secretary, and then actually put together a plan to hire somebody, not necessarily me, but we ended up with three great candidates and then two. And then I

Brandon Burton (15:27.425)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (15:54.488)
I won, I think. And I got the role. The other person, I will say, because it was down to two of us, the other person the board loved and said, we’re going to ask him to be on our board. And I said, so you’re going to call this guy and say, we’re not going to hire you, but we want you to come work for free. And I said, well, yeah, kind of. All right. So I called him. I didn’t know him from Adam. I called him the next week and scheduled lunch. And we became good friends. And he became our board chair.

Brandon Burton (15:56.663)
Yeah, you were the last remaining candidate. Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (16:24.055)
a few years after that. So it all worked out fine. But why I tell you all that is because at that point, I decided that I had run away from the chamber industry a number of times and that I wanted to or needed to admit that this is an industry that chose me, not the other way around. you know, no one is going to school to study to be a chamber executive. Little kids,

Brandon Burton (16:25.982)
You worked some good magic there, that’s awesome.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (16:53.303)
At Halloween, don’t dress up as chamber executives. It’s not something people think about. It’s all about just following the rules.

Brandon Burton (16:56.476)
Yeah.

You know what, Tony, I can totally see your persona at Spirit Halloween this year. anyways, we’ll send that in to him.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (17:04.757)
Yeah. With my little booby’s face and yeah. I’ll say maybe maybe as a visit organization because no, they they get a lot of fun things to do, but chambers not so much anyway. So once I I got this job, I just decided I needed to go in, you know, whole hog. So I was hired in May of 2007.

Brandon Burton (17:17.282)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (17:32.776)
And the following summer, I went to my first year of Chamber Institute, a chamber in Los Angeles, West is best, even though it doesn’t exist anymore. But I did four years of the US Chamber Institute, loved it, learned so much about it, continually talked to. By that point, I had peers in the LGBT chamber industry, kept trying to get them involved in it, and really the idea of professionalizing.

the LGBT chamber industry within the greater chamber industry. So I graduated from Institute, which was wonderful. excuse me, I was asked to serve on the board then, and then I was the board chair and all those things. You miss a meeting and the next thing you know, you’re the chair of something. And about two years later, the Association of Chamber of Commerce Executives was having a conference in Oklahoma City.

Brandon Burton (18:21.538)
That’s right, they nominate you while you’re gone.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (18:31.223)
So I I drove up there to see you know what this all about and there was somebody from my class getting their CCE and I thought hmm I should probably consider this because. I’m not going to remember more by waiting. I’m probably not going to get any smarter by waiting, so the next year I I applied and went through that program and became a certified Chamber Executive, which is I think one of the smartest things I ever did.

Brandon Burton (18:48.492)
Yeah, it’s true.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (19:00.951)
And now many years later, I’m thrilled to service the now the outgoing chair of the CCE commission. But I think that that trajectory that I took going to IOM, not fast tracking and trying to get it all done, but doing it one year at a time, which even then is drinking from a fire hose. It really gave me a better perspective of my role as CEO and

the board of directors and what their roles are. And so lately. It seems like there’s been a lot of. Stress between CEOs and boards or board chairs. And and I I find it. You know academically, I find it kind of interesting. I also find it a little bit scary since you know we do serve.

at the pleasure of our boards. And it seems to me some of the folks that I know who have been victims of this are really excellent people. mean, they’ve done great jobs within their chamber, but I’m always interested to see what is the what’s under the surface. And I think board training is a big part of it.

Brandon Burton (20:01.72)
Right.

Brandon Burton (20:22.744)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (20:26.039)
Now we don’t do everything perfect. I would be the first person to tell you that we don’t. I I tried very hard to do all the right things, but. We have a couple of things I think work incredibly well. First of all, our communication is outstanding many, many, many years ago we started our board chair and I started having a weekly meeting and I know that sounds like simple kind of thing and it is.

Brandon Burton (20:55.725)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (20:55.959)
Uh, you know, we just picked a time, put it on the calendar and we’d meet in my office or we meet virtually after COVID or during, you know, got used to doing that. Um, and sometimes we’d be talking about an issue that, that I saw on the horizon or something that was happening and, know, get their input and talk about it. And sometimes we would talk about RuPaul’s Drag Race. don’t know. I, you know, I mean, it was just a chance for us to touch base together and

Brandon Burton (21:03.768)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (21:26.185)
It helped because not everything is serious, problems all the time, but it just gave us both a better sense of who we are and what we’re doing. And there’s never been a time when I take the chamber duty of care, duty of loyalty, duty of obedience, I take those very seriously and I believe I’ve instilled that in our board as well. And along those lines, I would never challenge

my board chair in a board meeting. I just wouldn’t. You know, he and I or she and I, as we’ve had in the past, you know, we talk about things before me. There aren’t surprises at our board meeting. We do a good job of managing it. So funny, he sent me an email recently that he’s on another board and he said, I don’t know, it might end at noon, it might end at 4 p.m. And I thought, my God, who’s running this meeting?

Brandon Burton (22:00.047)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (22:24.48)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (22:26.113)
I mean, we do our chamber board, our foundation board, and we’re done in less than 90 minutes. So, you know, it’s well crafted, anyhow. But, you know, I think it’s important that we, you I support him. If I disagree with something, you know, we’re going to figure out how to get to the point where I can’t agree with him because I think that’s my issue or that I’ve convinced him otherwise.

Brandon Burton (22:34.146)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (22:55.223)
that I think we often see in some of these other incidents where a board chair will go to a chamber, to a CEO, and say, we’re going to let you go. Now, does the rest of the board know that? Or is this something the board has decided to do on their own? none of us work, you know, the board chair is obviously the person that we deal with one-on-one, but we work for the board.

Brandon Burton (23:11.747)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (23:22.818)
The board, yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (23:24.083)
And so those should be discussions that we have to board.

Brandon Burton (23:27.566)
Well, I’ve heard of board members too, you know, going to fire the chamber executive. Is this your decision? But as the executive, do you really want to stay there if that’s the hostility that’s happening? And so there’s obviously some dysfunction, which goes back to your point of communication and the board training. But sorry, I didn’t mean to cut you off.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (23:49.514)
No, no, you’re absolutely right and probably kind of going back before that even is recruitment. And so something I learned from somebody that another nonprofit who had been CEO for like 30 years or something like that is that the key to longevity is to be very active in your board recruitment. I will meet with people that members of ours that I.

Brandon Burton (23:58.114)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (24:17.303)
kept an eye on or I’ve told another board member who’s on the same committee, keep an eye on them, let me know and I’ll meet with them. Usually my conversation is something like, I cannot ask you to join the board. I can ask you to apply and then we go through the whole process and I try to give them probably more information than most would upfront. We go over all the financials.

Brandon Burton (24:42.765)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (24:43.863)
We go over a lot of things because I don’t want them to waste their time applying and then later go. So so that’s how we start. And so there’s an understanding of what their responsibility is. And certainly, if I got the sense that there’s somebody who hates me and wants me to be gone, I would be suggesting to the board chair that maybe they not advance in the process. That hasn’t happened yet.

Brandon Burton (24:48.429)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (25:11.011)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (25:13.833)
about every two years, we rotate board members or board chairs every two years. And when the new board chair comes in, I always tell them that when the board is ready for me to go, they want to go a different direction. Just tell me and I’ll pack up my toys and leave. And, know, that’s fine. I don’t want all the drama. Just, you know, and usually their response is, why are you leaving? It’s like, no.

Brandon Burton (25:32.618)
Yes.

Brandon Burton (25:40.632)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (25:42.008)
But I want you to realize I know that I serve at your pleasure. Yeah, the fact that I’ve been here 20 years is kind of surprising to me, but are almost 20 years. But yeah, I think there’s just a need for greater communication between chairs and CEOs and chairs and the rest of the board.

Brandon Burton (25:47.032)
There’s a shelf life to these things, right?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (26:09.847)
You know the board chairs responsibilities aren’t just to run the meeting. You know you could you know get trained monkey to do that, but the board chairs job is to make everybody on the board successful. So if the board board members have goals that they’re supposed to meet responsibilities, it’s up to the board chair to be working with them to make sure that they are successful and that we’re all on the same page. We’re all rowing in the right direction. All that that kind of thing so.

I think that if you don’t have the proper recruitment, if you’re heaven forbid an organization that elects your board by popular ballot, I’m not sure I be CEO of an organization like that because you end up with the popular people who may not have the skills you need to run your organization. But mine is not the only way, although it should be probably.

Brandon Burton (26:56.834)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (27:03.436)
Right.

Brandon Burton (27:08.59)
That’s right. I wish you’d have an opinion about something, you know?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (27:09.545)
Yeah. I tell my husband that all the time. But yeah, you know, it’s it starts with the recruitment and the training and that communication with your board chair and and being just really good partners in the work that you’re doing. I think something that helps both executives and and boards.

is for the executive to have a very clearly written contract with the organization. One that anticipates possible mutiny from a board member or two and that provides some kind of financial support for the CEO should someone decide to go rogue and want to get rid of this person. For example, yes, if you know.

We can let you go without cause, but will pay you a year salary. Wow. That that’s going to that’s going to cause a little bit of pause for some board members go. Oh, do we want to do that? Or do we want to get rid of this board member who’s mucking things up? You know things like that. And also we have the issue of. Of boards that are trying. They’re they’re the well meaning people, but.

Brandon Burton (28:09.165)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (28:16.45)
Maybe we don’t want to be so quick.

Brandon Burton (28:23.17)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (28:34.739)
they get in the way of management. you know, there are certain things that the staff does, certain things that the board does. And when the board starts moving out of their lane and into the staff lane, especially of a staff of more than two of us, it can be very confusing for the staff. Who am I supposed to be listening to? And it undermines the CEO and those kinds of things. So

Brandon Burton (28:37.517)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (28:59.224)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (29:04.343)
I think, and I’ve said the word communication so many times, I should be paid by the word. But I think communication with the board chair and a great training and understanding by everybody on the board. And when you have those situations where you have the rogue board member, again, it’s up to the board chair. And nobody likes confrontation.

It’s that’s the time they have to put on their big boy pants or big girl pants, either ones and. Address address the matter or you end up with somebody who’s made the CEOs life hell and you may lose that person voluntarily or not.

Brandon Burton (29:43.758)
soon.

Brandon Burton (29:51.289)
Yeah. So we’ve brought up the idea of board training multiple times now. Who should facilitate the board training? What have you seen? What would be some good piece of advice on who facilitates that?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (30:06.743)
I am a firm believer. Somebody told me this many years ago. I’m a firm believer in the fact that the that the expert is whoever came from furthest away. So. Yeah, yeah, and and that you know profit is never accepted in their own land. So the Texas Chamber of Commerce executives where we spoke last year does a board board chair.

Brandon Burton (30:17.516)
That’s right. The person from out of town. Yeah.

Brandon Burton (30:32.632)
Yeah.

Thank

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (30:35.479)
training to talk about these issues and chairs and CEOs. And gosh, I forgot what I was going to say about that chairs and CEOs. yeah. And so you find people that are doing their own board training.

But even with us, we bring somebody in every now and then. And we go over all of our board stuff every January. I’m not sure how much the board appreciates it, but I always have that on the agenda. But we’ll go to that meeting. As hard as I’ve tried to make sure they know everything, we will go to that meeting and somebody will say something that I’ve been saying for years. And suddenly, my God, what a great idea. We should do that.

Brandon Burton (31:21.454)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (31:25.278)
I’ve been saying that to you. And so, and that’s fine. As long as the message finally gets there, I’m okay. But it’s true. Exactly. So I think if you can have somebody else come in, and I know in North Texas, the chambers are great here about switching off with each other and find a different CEO to come in.

Brandon Burton (31:33.122)
Yeah. Well, it’s like children never listen to their parents either. So it’s the same kind of principle.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (31:52.502)
and do your board training. Or someone from a training organization or something. That’s always going to be vast. If you can remove yourself from the process, be part of the people being trained so that you’re hearing the same thing everybody else is hearing is ideal. But in a pinch, I guess you could do it yourself, but don’t expect the best results.

Brandon Burton (31:59.182)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (32:22.263)
from that. And the reminder. No. Who are you? Oh yeah. But again, a lot of it has to do documentation as well, so most boards will have a job description for the board members. They may have a code of conduct which we have. They may have something describing their responsibilities. They’re given get their attendance, those kinds of things.

Brandon Burton (32:22.444)
Yeah, because they’re not going to hear you. that’s right. Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (32:52.119)
understanding of the legal responsibilities, the duty of care, loyalty and obedience. Any other important policies to organization, we have an anti harassment policy that we make sure is always in front of new board members and then part of our annual review of documents. So I would like to think everybody reads those every year, but I’m not stupid. we do.

Brandon Burton (33:16.024)
Yeah

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (33:20.769)
put them out there and we make sure that they know these are the documents that are there so they know they exist. And and they’re required to sign off on them. For some reason, when people sign things, they tend to pay attention to them a little bit more. Who knows?

Brandon Burton (33:25.976)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (33:36.781)
Yeah.

Yeah, that’s interesting. So I think we’ve covered a lot here. A lot should, you know, that should give listeners stuff to kind of chew on and maybe rethink the approach that they take with their board. And especially when it comes to board training and how are we communicating these things openly and upfront. I like the part that you mentioned about the contract too, that you have with the Chamber.

If you can work in something in there about a separation clause and some kind of a severance, you know, payout that will help to keep the ship a little more steady, I think, when things might get heated, but you guys can come to level heads as you work through that.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (34:14.903)
Mm-hmm.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (34:26.007)
You know, it’s important if you go that route and I highly recommend that you, the CEO, hire your own attorney. I wouldn’t tell the board that you’ve hired an attorney because that just, you know, lawyering up sounds like really tough. But make sure that you have somebody reading the agreement on your side to give you some advice. And one the things that we’ve always had, and I had

Brandon Burton (34:42.028)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (34:53.227)
great examples from wonderful North Texas leaders many years ago, but that cause for being let go is clearly defined. So these are things that are cause. Anything else is not, and that that’s an important part of it. I also think people need to take advantage. I wish they would of what’s available to them at whatever level, so we should all be budgeting.

for continuing education so that we can be part of our regional chamber executives group. I know in Texas we have a Gulf Coast Chamber of Execs, we the North Texas Chamber Execs, and I’m guessing somewhere in West Texas there’s something too, but I don’t know for sure. But, you know, so that local regional group

You’re statewide Texas Chamber of Executives. Most states have an executive association and then you know the the king of them all or queen. A CCE is is kind of the top of it and of course these are all separate and you have to be so produced for all of them, which is another thing I would work into a contract that that the Chamber pays for your executive. Dues in different organizations.

Brandon Burton (35:59.843)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (36:16.654)
trainings and everything.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (36:19.703)
But just the fact that it gives you an opportunity to network with some people, you know, there’s only one of you. So, you know, there aren’t many people that know what you’re going through or what you’re dealing with. But once you have that network, most people in the chamber industry that I’ve met, I should say not most, but all have been very welcoming.

Brandon Burton (36:28.419)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (36:46.849)
happy to assist, share documentation, anything. And so I think those are the kinds of things that will help, as I said earlier, professionalize the industry. So that you may have been hired because you know how to put on an event that is important to the chamber. But your real work as a chamber is advocacy.

How do I learn about advocacy? Well, here’s a chamber that has a great advocacy committee and I’m going to learn from them, put my own committee together and stay at Austin, yada, yada. But I think those things and look for the training that’s available. Of course, IOM, think is a great preface before working on your CCE, which I highly recommend, not only because I’m curing commission and I’m supposed to say that.

Brandon Burton (37:18.264)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (37:43.256)
but also, ACCE has some, training modules that you can do. So find out what you’re not good at. you know, if. Event production is something you’re not good at, but finances well, skip financing, you know, take the class on event production or membership or advocacy or whatever it is. but, I think this is going to sound terrible. So this is only seen by chamber executives, right?

Brandon Burton (37:51.139)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (38:13.175)
Or members can watch this. The more you can do to position yourself as the subject matter expert in the industry, the better off you’ll be. So I have members who.

Brandon Burton (38:14.028)
Right. No board members see this yet.

Brandon Burton (38:29.891)
Yeah.

As Seth Godin says, be the linchpin for your organization.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (38:36.553)
Absolutely yeah, I have members who wants an insurance agent and ones of corporate HR person and ones are realtor and they’re all experts in what they do. They don’t know how to run the chamber. And so if you don’t make yourself that expert and and. Help them see you as that expert. Then you’re doing yourself a disservice, but I I am.

thrilled that you board members will often defer to me and they’ll ask me well what’s what what do other chambers do? What’s in the industry and things like that? I’m fortunate I’ve been in this job for almost 20 years now and I try to remember that there are some advantages to that. The level of trust that my board has in me is incredibly high, which I would.

Brandon Burton (39:12.653)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (39:34.675)
never do anything to hurt that trust. But when you’re new, you don’t always have that. And in starting with the education and getting to, again, make yourself that subject matter expert is key.

Brandon Burton (39:50.627)
Yeah, very good. Well, Tony, as we start to wrap up, I wanted to ask for the listeners who are trying to take their organization up to the next level. What kind of tip or action item would you share with them as they strive towards that goal?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (40:05.002)
Hmm. Run, do not walk to the nearest exit. No, I’m just kidding. Yeah, I’ll tell you this is a challenge for all of us. Because we all want to elevate our organization and. It takes time having. Organic growth is difficult. Slow.

Brandon Burton (40:09.004)
Hahaha!

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (40:32.79)
But I think often the best. I I some some communities do very well at big membership campaigns and God bless them. I’m I’m thrilled that that that works for them. I don’t think for my community it would again because we’re targeting. LGBT and ally businesses, not everybody within you know the confines of a severe county so.

That doesn’t work, but it works great for other people. So that’s slow, very slow. Organic growth is good. Communication with your members is something that I’ll admit I let go of a little bit after hiring Lisa. Every now and then I bemoan the fact that that for years I could I could name every member.

Brandon Burton (41:22.242)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (41:30.134)
We had, would see them. I know their name. I know their company. Now I’m lucky to remember my name most of the time, but you know that that kind of connection is always helpful. Following through on things that you tell your members you’re going to. You’re going to do for them. And there was another thing I was going to say about next level. Must have been a lie. Yeah.

Brandon Burton (41:57.657)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (41:59.991)
You know, I think, I know what I was going to say. So I belong to an executive group, CEOs of LGBT organizations or CEOs who are themselves LGBT. We get together twice a month and we swear it’s not therapy. But nonetheless, yeah. But it gives us all a chance to talk about

Brandon Burton (42:22.382)
It helps.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (42:29.362)
employees and boards and things like that in a very safe and confidential environment. If you don’t have that, I suggest you get one of those. But the woman that facilitates for us asked us last year for a word that, you know, our word for the year, and I still don’t know what mine was, but then a new one for this year. And I picked two and I said, my words this year are focus and delegate.

Brandon Burton (42:38.403)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (42:59.19)
And I’m very much trying to do that. Stay focused on the things that are important that I do. There’s a lot of things that we could do. Are they really important? Perry Cole once told me, so it was a long time ago in Albuquerque, not to let the immediate overshadow the important. So somebody may come to you and their hair is on fire for some reason.

Brandon Burton (43:16.717)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (43:23.299)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (43:29.142)
you know, that’s fine for them, but you know, their emergency doesn’t necessarily have to be yours. So what’s immediate? What’s important? Focus on what’s important and then delegate. So I have two words this year. Focus and delegate. So one of the things that I can again, we’re very small to staff members, but there are board members who would be willing to do some things. So what board members could I ask to do some little thing or

Brandon Burton (43:43.585)
I like that.

Brandon Burton (43:51.054)
Thank

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (43:57.697)
to serve on a city committee so that I don’t have to go to all of them. Those kinds of things. So focus and delegate and check with me in a year or so and I’ll let you know if it takes us to the next level or not.

Brandon Burton (44:04.32)
you

Brandon Burton (44:12.014)
I also like asking about the future of chambers and how you see the future of chambers and their purpose going forward.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (44:20.688)
great question. And of course, I only say great questions so I can be thinking about a good answer. You know, if you had asked me this pre-COVID, I would say that we’re all trying to redefine our relevance and what it is we do. So my first chamber job in Albuquerque was in the

Brandon Burton (44:26.142)
Right? That pause.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (44:51.06)
late 70s, early 80s, I think. And we were just at the end of the period where people joined the chamber because it was the right thing to do. And so we get to that period and people aren’t joining because it’s the right thing to do anymore. And they’re not joining because it’s about supporting community. They’re doing it because they want to increase their sales. They want to have networking, those kinds of things.

And that was a major shift in chambers, and that’s why you see a lot of chambers that do a lot of networking programs and I we do them as well. I. I sometimes try to miss them, but but it’s enjoyable to see my member, so it’s like that’s OK. I’ll come and then put on my I love to dance, smile and talk to people. But but they get so focused on that they forget that.

the idea of a chamber of commerce back in the 1600s was to represent business to government. And so that advocacy piece has always been there, whether people have recognized it or not. You will still find chambers that say, we’re not political. Well, it’s not be political, but you have to be advocating for something. mean, you know, taxes or

Brandon Burton (45:56.568)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (46:12.225)
Right.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (46:15.158)
permit use or whatever, I don’t know, but there has to be things that are important to your members. If I can advocate on an issue that’s gonna affect 90 % of our members, that is a much better use of my time than a networking event that’s going to assist maybe 20 % of them. but pre-COVID, I would say, you know, people are still looking for that, whatever. COVID proved that we are relevant and that

Brandon Burton (46:32.226)
Great.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (46:44.906)
There were a lot of things that we did to connect small businesses that made a huge difference. I know in Texas, we were one of the chambers that distributed COVID tests to small businesses. There are arts organizations and our bars and restaurants. They kept us running out of them because they needed them for their continual testing. So that was a way that we were able to connect a service to the business community that

might not have been served before. And same thing with financial support from the federal government, making sure people understood what was out there, how to get the money, what’s involved. So all those advocating for a small business or providing them with support that they need in a broader sense really came to light during COVID and proved that chambers are relevant.

We may do things a little different like this, but we’re still about helping businesses grow, helping our communities thrive, and for ours, of course, advancing equality.

Brandon Burton (47:46.339)
Yeah.

Brandon Burton (47:59.875)
Yeah, very good. Well, Tony, this has been a great conversation and hopefully those listening have been jotting down some notes, at least getting some thoughts spinning about how they want to have some conversation with their board and be better at recruiting and looking out for themselves. But I wanted to give you an opportunity to share any contact information for anyone listening who might want to reach out and connect with you or learn more about your approach. Where would you point them and what would be the best way to connect?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (48:29.172)
Yeah, just yesterday told someone gave them my phone number and I said, you know, give me a call. I I answer sometimes, but. Yeah, my my direct dial number is 214-865-6516 and that comes to my desk and if my phone systems working properly to my cell phone at some point. I do return phone calls.

Brandon Burton (48:36.086)
Yeah. I recognize the number, right?

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (48:58.07)
And then my email address. I think it’s pretty darn easy to remember. It’s my name tony.vedda@lgbtqchamber.com. So and if you mess up and you put the Q, I’ll still get it. I got we have a lot of email things, but yeah, email is always great if.

If you’re in North Texas and need a connection to the North Texas Chamber of Executives, I’d be happy to facilitate that. If you want more information on the Association of Chamber of Commerce Executives or the CCE program, I’m happy to provide that or connect with folks there. So give me a call, send me an email. Don’t hit me up on social media because I’m not often there. I’m on Facebook about once a month.

Brandon Burton (49:46.274)
Yeah.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (49:49.77)
Whether I need to be or not, that’s about it.

Brandon Burton (49:51.596)
Yeah, yeah, very good. Well, we’ll be sure to get this in the show notes for this episode so people can find you. But again, Tony, thanks for setting aside some time and spending it with us here on Chamber Chat podcast. I appreciate it and appreciate your experiences and stories you had to share with us as well. Thank you.

Tony Vedda, CCE, IOM (50:09.153)
Well, thank you for having me. I appreciate it. Have a good day.


If you are a chamber professional, please subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast in Apple podcast, Google podcasts, Spotify or now on YouTube. When you subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast new episodes will show up in your feed each week as they are released. If you’re finding value in this podcast, please leave us a rating and a review in iTunes. But most importantly, please share Chamber Chat Podcast with your colleagues that are in the industry.

Get started with your own Chamber Podcast and shortcut your learning curve with the Chamber Podcast Course offered by Chamber Chat Podcast.
Have you considered the many benefits of hosting a podcast for your Chamber? The options, leverage, and possibilities that a podcast offers are virtually endless. Download my FREE Chamber Podcasting Guide to learn how to start your own Chamber podcast!

Negotiating Compensation & Benefits with Bob Thomas

Miles Burdine Chamber Chat Podcast promo image.

Below is an auto-generated transcription. Because this is auto-generated there are likely some grammatical errors but it is still a useful tool to search text within this podcast episode.

Feel free to join our Chamber Chat Champions Facebook Group to discuss this episode and to share your own experiences and tips with other Chamber Champions.

Brandon Burton 0:00
This is the Chamber Chat Podcast, the show dedicated to chamber professionals to spark ideas and to get actionable tips and strategies to better serve your members and community.

Hello, Chamber Champions. Welcome to Chamber Chat Podcast. I’m your hosts Brandon Burton. And it’s my goal here on the podcast to introduce you to people and ideas to better help you serve your Chamber members and your community.

Our title sponsor for this episode is Bringing Local Back. Remember when your community could turn to a local TV station or newspaper for the latest updates and affordable ads? Those days may be fading, but the need for local connection remains. That’s why we created Bringing Local Back, a game changing platform that restores the local visibility and advertising power to your community. It’s more than just tech. It’s about driving engagement and creating new revenue for your chamber. Ready to see the future visit bringinglocalback.com to schedule your demo today. This is the future of local commerce.

Our guest for this episode is Bob Thomas. Bob is the Chief Operating Officer and integrator for the Michigan Chamber of Commerce and Executive Director for the Michigan Chamber Foundation. Bob is a widely respected chamber and Association Executive with over 27 years of experience in the nonprofit industry. He served as the primary operations staff member since 2012 Bob is responsible for day to day operations of the chamber, including facilities, technology and information systems, human resources and finance. Bob also assists with strategic planning, revenue development, membership and meetings management. His accomplishments include assisting the chamber to achieve three designations as an accredited State Chamber with distinction as executive director for the Michigan chamber foundation. Bob oversees alignment and direction of its leadership programs, public policy, research and events related to free enterprise, competitiveness, leadership and entrepreneurship. Bob, I’m excited to have you with us today here on Chamber Chat Podcast. I’d love to give you an opportunity to say hello to all the Chamber Champions who are out there listening, and to share something interesting about yourself so we can all get to know you a little better. Hey,

Bob Thomas 2:23
Chamber Champions, glad to finally make it on the Chamber Podcast, Chamber Chat Podcast, it’s my pleasure to be here. Interesting fact about me, I set a goal about 10 years ago to see all 50 states before I turned 50, and I checked my last state off the list this last year with Alaska. Alaska.

Brandon Burton 2:45
That’s a good that’s a good capstone for or your 50th state. It’s a beautiful state.

Bob Thomas 2:51
Great trip.

Brandon Burton 2:53
Yeah, for a lot of people, I know they wanted to be much higher on their list of places to be, and it probably was for you as well. It’s just a matter of getting there.

Bob Thomas 3:00
That’s right, it’s probably the hardest one to get there, but it’s well, actually the Dakota is for the hardest one, because those weren’t necessarily a destination on my list, but I was actually pleasantly surprised everybody should actually make it to North and South Dakota as well.

Brandon Burton 3:15
Yeah, there you go. Shout out to North and South Dakota. Well, tell us a little bit about the Michigan chamber, just to give us an idea and set the stage for our discussion today, I usually like asking about the size of the chamber, staff, budget, scope of work. It’s a little bit different being a State Chamber, but give us the background and information on the Michigan chamber that could be helpful to listeners.

Bob Thomas 3:39
Sure. So we are a statewide Chamber of Commerce, one of almost 50 in the country. We are based here in the state’s capital, Lansing, Michigan. We’re just four blocks down from the State Capitol building. We have 29 staff, most of them are in our membership development and engagement teams. And then we have a $6 million budget, sometimes up to $8 million depending on whether or not and it’s an election year, because our main value proposition is certainly our advocacy components and how we connect our members to state government, legislators, other elected officials, and we pride ourselves on participating in the election process to help make sure that we’re getting pro business candidates there to represent Michigan’s over 200,000 businesses in the state. Yeah. So

Brandon Burton 4:35
as we’re recording this, this is the the first of November, 2024 so hopefully you guys are looking forward to a little bit of reprieve after next week with the with the elections, and be able to take a little bit of a sigh

Bob Thomas 4:47
of relief, hopefully, hopefully a sigh of relief. But

Brandon Burton 4:52
nonetheless, right,

Bob Thomas 4:55
every election presents new opportunities for us to represent our members and so. We’ll see what that brings us next week.

Brandon Burton 5:01
Yeah, fantastic. Well, as we get into our topic today, I think this is one of those topics that everyone listening can relate to in one way or another, as we talk about focusing our conversation around negotiating compensation and benefits. And I think you know, depending on where you are in your your career at a chamber, if you’re just starting out, if you’re just looking to get in to the chamber industry, or if you’re a long time seasoned chamber veteran, or somebody on the tail end of your career, hopefully we’ll be able to touch on on all those different aspects throughout this episode, as as Bob’s with us today to share some of his insights, and we’ll we’ll dive in much deeper on this topic. As soon as we get back from this quick break.

Are you looking for a year round affordable and timely shop local campaign for your chamber or CVB Look no further build a custom each shop play mobile app with App My Community by visiting appmycommunity.com/chamberchat. App My Community mobile apps are not just simple membership directory listings. They provide many more capabilities to engage with your community. Provide your residents with a robust events calendar partner with a local fare festival or Farmers Market provide a schedule map and other resources to promote the event. Run a Small Business Saturday campaign any time of the year using built in scavenger hunts allow your membership to communicate directly to their customers via push notifications. Your app my community mobile app will be a unique member benefit allow you to generate non dues revenue with sponsorship opportunities and best of all provide a valuable resource to your community please visit appmycommunity.com/chamberchat now to receive 10% off your first year of an App My Community mobile app.

App My Community creates mobile apps that allow you to engage directly with your community. Enhance chamber membership by providing a unique advertising and communication channel to residents and visitors. Not just a member directory, App My Community has the tools to be useful to residents on a daily basis. Learn more at appmycommunity.com/chamberchat.

Attention all chamber of commerce leaders! Are you looking for a powerful tool to help grow and manage your chamber? Look no further than Chamber Nation! Our comprehensive platform provides all the features you need to streamline membership management, host events, communicate with your members and provide amazing services to your members. Plus, our expert team is always available to provide personalized support. Don’t miss out on this opportunity to take your chamber to the next level at a price you will truly appreciate. Visit www.RichardsCalendar.com to learn more about Chamber Nation today!

Visit ChamberNation.com to learn more.

All right, Bob, we’re back, and as I mentioned before the break, we’re talking today about negotiating compensation and benefits, which I know can be a very important topic for for those in the chamber world, but really for anybody. But also it can be a very uncomfortable topic for somebody to approach and to to say, here’s what I need. And just having some of those conversations that can be a little more difficult. So I’m hopeful that our in our conversation today, that we’ll be able to come, come out of this with some takeaways that could be helpful in giving that that encouragement and that support to help people have those conversations. So I’m going to hand the hand the mic over to you and share with us what what comes to mind first, when you when you think about negotiating compensation benefits, maybe from the perspective of somebody new or just coming into the chamber world,

Bob Thomas 8:28
sure. Well, I think most of the listeners can commiserate that we didn’t necessarily join the chamber for the money, that there are probably lots of other opportunities out there for us to make more money, but they don’t always necessarily line up with our life circumstance, our passion points, or even, you know, what we’re committed to doing as a career and so and that makes it sometimes more difficult when we’re talking about negotiating or asking for compensation that matches our unique abilities and the skills that we’re bringing to the table, because the budgets don’t always necessarily match what those abilities are. But I would say, you know, for folks who are looking at a chamber job, or are earlier in their career on a chamber job, there’s lots of questions that they should be asking themselves before they go into the negotiating process so that they’re best prepared to ask for what is reasonable and appropriate for their level of job. And the first one, I think, that we tend to overlook is what is the market actually paying for these jobs? And and on one hand, we could be looking at, you know, similar organizations, other nonprofits, or other chambers of commerce that have similar markets, but that data isn’t always accurate or fair to the talents that we’re bringing to the table. So I would always encourage folks to also look at. Are similar jobs paying in the private sector and to see what is a good match, you know? So if I’m a marketing and membership person, what are other marketing level jobs paying for similar size organizations? Or if I’m an accountant, you know, what are other accounting jobs paying for summer situation? So that’s the first one. I just know what is the market even available for that kind of a position? Yeah, I think

Brandon Burton 10:26
if you’re, if we’re strictly looking at other nonprofits, you’re going to immediately put yourself as at a little bit of a disadvantage, because I think chamber staff, they wear so many hats, and it’s not, it’s not necessarily like other nonprofit organizations, where you have the scope, and that’s that’s all you do, because everybody brings everything to the chamber and expect you to be magicians and figure it out. So if you can bring that skill set and say, here’s where these things fit in the private sector, this is what I’m worth. I think that’s great advice, yeah,

Bob Thomas 10:55
but with a caveat, because sometimes the first place where we shoot ourselves in the foot is we look at large mass market surveys like salary.com or Glassdoor, and those are really helpful to kind of give you a range, but that’s an average of lots of different size organizations, and so sometimes we either are over inflated, or, in the case of other nonprofits, under representing what our value potentially is to the organization. So I would say, especially if you’re already in the chamber world and you have access to your state survey or to the ACCE benchmarking data, those are great places to look.

Brandon Burton 11:29
Yeah, that’s that’s good advice. Being able to see what what other peers are getting is very helpful.

Bob Thomas 11:38
And don’t be afraid to talk about it with the network. I think chamber folks are more transparent than others to help share where they’re at and how they can help lift each other up. Yeah, they’re also probably your best supporters. For you to figure out what your value is, again, chambers tend to attract a lot of servant type workers, and so we go in with the idea of, I love this work, I’m happy to do it, but we don’t always emphasize what our value is to the organization. And so then sometimes we take less or ask for less than what we are due because we love the work so much that we’ll, we’ll do it for less. Yeah, and that doesn’t always set yourself up for sell your set yourself up for a long term success if you’re going to start on the low end.

Brandon Burton 12:31
Now, I’m from the maybe on the hiring perspective. You know, as we’ve got a lot of executives that are listening, some their boards give a lot of leeway, not a lot, maybe, but a lot might be generous, but give them some leeway as far as what salary could be for staff and others are very tightly controlled by their board. So I hope through our conversation today, we can integrate some of that too. How do we approach this at the board and show where the value lies in bringing on staff and our own self worth as well.

Bob Thomas 13:06
Yeah, well, that’s actually my next point is understand what the decision making process is. So if you’re a staff member going to the executive and asking for a raise, or you’re trying to negotiate your compensation, I think the last thing most executives want is a surprise number. I think this is a regular conversation you should be having with your boss in general about what your long term expectations are for your career and for what your compensation will look like, and how that might ebb and flow based on your personal needs. And that would give them an idea about when they can be an advocate for you with the board, or when they need to be more transparent with the budget, but just to have that open conversation and when it does come down to board clamps that are really difficult to get away from, at least understand, when do they have to take it to the board, and when would it get shot down in that particular case, or when is there a leeway so that you can take advantage of those opportunities to grow your compensation, but definitely have that transparent conversation, either with your board chair, if you’re the exec, or with your boss, so that they know kind of what you’re thinking and where Your goals are long term.

Brandon Burton 14:20
Yeah, I think that’s that’s good. I like the idea of the long term expectations. Have those conversations being had along the way. Say, Yeah, I’m new to the chamber now, but you know, down the road, this is what, how I’d like to see my career develop. I’d like to be at the Chamber long term, or this is a stopping point for a year or two, while I finish my degree, or while I do whatever it may be, and just being open and transparent, I think, helps both sides figure out what’s what’s the best and what’s most fair as far as compensation goes, Yeah,

Bob Thomas 14:51
at least give your boss a chance to come back and say that’s probably not going to work. You know, if it’s not realistic to match with your budget or these are the things that. Need to change in order for us to be able to afford that. Or, yeah, we could do that, but this is how you need to progress within your position in order to achieve that number. I think when you have that conversation, that makes it easier. It’s less of a surprise and less uncomfortable year after year, if you’re starting off a transparent foot, right?

Brandon Burton 15:21
So I’m always curious about the the more seasoned chamber professional that chambers are unique and that you you’re tied in with your community. You’re, you’re running things in the community, you know all the players. You’re, you know, convening. You’re bringing people together. But some seasoned chamber professionals feel the only way to advance in their career is to move to another community, to take another position at maybe a larger chamber. Is that true, or is that a fallacy? How can that seasoned chamber professional approach growth within their career path?

Bob Thomas 15:57
While I’ve seen that in Michigan and really with some of my colleagues from across the country, that is a real opportunity. And if you’re willing to up your route yourself and move to another community or another state, that probably is a great way to increase your compensation most quickly. But I don’t know that that’s realistic, especially for folks who have families or their kids are in school. You know you can potentially be looking at 12 to 15 years in a community where your kids are and that doesn’t really make it feasible for you to leave or perhaps your spouse or partner has a great job and they’re not willing to leave that either. So you know, there are lots of different reasons why you might have strings to a community that doesn’t make it easy for you to move to another community for a better paying job. And so when you think about that, those are the times to think about. You know, how can you grow the pot or the resources? How do you communicate with your board, what your intent is for staying with the chamber? I think most boards would find comfort in knowing that they’ve got some longevity in a leader for their organization, but not all. And so making sure that you’re going to bat for yourself with those folks who are also holding the purse strings to understand your value and to be able to negotiate that. And so one of the suggestions I have in those cases, especially if you’re in a community longer than five years, you should be creating that pat on the back file and documenting what your impact is every year so that you can show progress or achievements that you’ve been making within the chamber and remind the board what you’re doing in order to make that impact and how the chamber is progressing, and then try and link whatever your request is to organization goals. So if the board’s interest is in growing revenue, or if it’s in growing membership, tie your request for increasing compensation to those accomplishments and show how you’re going to get there or how you’ve achieved it, and why you’re due additional compensation. I know that a lot of chambers, especially if you’re small and mid sized, don’t always have the growth in revenue that would allow a year over year increase regularly. So a couple other solutions that you might ask for in lieu of a one time jump. And I know a lot of chambers, I’ve been successful with this, most recently, because of the inflationary increases, is try and phase it in over a period of time. So rather than going from a 2% increase to a 10% increase, could you do a two to five to seven or 10% increase over two or three years, that makes it more palatable for the board to absorb, and gives you more time to raise the resources to help fund that. Another one would be to think about alternatives to dollars. So if the short term need is that you need to pay for child care, or you’ve got an increased commute, could you ask for a car allowance or a child care stipend for that period of time rather than asking for a raise? So for boards, that’s a short term cash solution that helps retain you, that’s not necessarily tied to long term increases, but gets you through the things that you need in order to continue to work at the chamber. So those are just a couple of suggestions. If you’re not able to negotiate a large increase, figure out and have a transparent conversation about what do you need so that you can help bridge that gap.

Brandon Burton 19:36
Yeah, I like the idea of even being open to alternatives, too, to be able to say, here’s here’s some of the struggling or the pain points that I’m seeing and how obstacles that I need to be able to overcome in order to stay in this position. Yeah. How can you help me accomplish this? And again, it goes back to having that open and transparent conversation, which, if you’re doing the job that you need to be doing, there. Going to want to retain you and keep you there, and hopefully they’ll work with you to do that. I always think of especially with the the executive position, where you’re often in the same conversations with the city manager or the school superintendent and and you look at the salaries that these individuals are having, and you’re all working towards progress in the community in different ways, from different angles. And I think my personal opinion is the compensation should be a little closer to what they’re making, keeping in mind that everything you know, they have different responsibilities and whatnot as well. But if you’re expected to be in the same room, in the same conversations, the same table, with these other decision makers, these other influencers in the community, compensation should be more in that ballpark than having them way up here in the chamber, exec way down there. I don’t know if you have any other thoughts at that, or how to approach that, or bring that up at the board, yeah,

Bob Thomas 21:00
well, that is a great point, and making sure that in strategic planning, you’re talking with your board about what are the expectations of your leadership as the exec, and that if you are supposed to carry the same weight in that room, you know compensation is one element, access to resources, being able to commit to positions or have a conversation without always having to go back to the board. Are important elements that, you know, help create that equity, but they also have different pots of money and different resources than a lot of chambers. Sometimes it’s a much broader, bigger pot because of the tax base versus private volunteer investment in dues. But to that point, if a chamber Exec is able to garner those resources and they can start to match or create a fund that allows them to pay for that position, then absolutely the board should be looking at at that as some of those comparables in terms of position or responsibility, and so to that point, be thoughtful about who is on your compensation committee and helping to make those decisions. So are they other small business people who look at your compensation and you know, are looking at it through a lens about have and have not, or are they leaders in the community who recognize what the investment is in the chamber in order to move the agenda forward, and so also be thoughtful about are there elected leaders who are on that compensation committee who maybe aren’t making as much as the chamber director? Because in some cases, it could be a downtown development person, or it could be a city manager who isn’t clearing that that same kind of salary compensation, and so just be thoughtful about how you have staffed that compensation committee in order to give yourself the fairest shake possible. That’s

Brandon Burton 22:58
a really good point. Just being intentional about that. Who’s on there? What? What perspectives are they coming from, and how do they perceive you compared to themselves or others that they might see in a similar light as yourself? That’s That’s great advice. So you mentioned a couple different alternatives to compensation. Are there other other thoughts you have around alternatives, or maybe other ideas that it because sometimes to get to that outside the box thinking, some ideas need to be brought to the table. You can’t just say, here’s the problem. Solve it, right? As chamber leaders, chamber staff like we’re in the business of solving problems, so I think to be able to bring some ideas of alternatives to the table could be helpful.

Bob Thomas 23:46
Yeah, I mean, I think executives a lot of times don’t recognize the art that comes to their budgets, and sometimes the easiest money that they that they leave on the table are performance bonuses or bonuses tied to metrics that you’ve improved. So are there opportunities to ask for a percentage of net increase or percentage of margin at the end of the year or at the end of a quarter for exceptional performance? So maybe you had an event that you really knocked out of the park and it cleared a major revenue hurdle with sponsorship, or you had a bang up here with membership and fundraising. Are you asking for a percentage at the end of the year as part of that performance bonus? And that’s something that could waiver or change from year to year, that could be negotiated, or maybe it’s something that you build into an employment agreement, so that is something that you can count on and the board can budget for every year. I think that’s the first thing that’s easiest to budget for and also ask for. But other things, you know, chambers are amazing organizations to work with in terms of flexibility and because we work. Lots of different hours based on our event schedules or needs of the organization. You know, having that flexibility to come and go from the office or come and go from events is a tremendous one. So if you’re not actively using that as a method of your compensation or employment agreement, that could be something in lieu of compensation that you might not get at a for profit organization, professional development budgets, again, those are things that could be incorporated into your budget, especially if you’re looking to complete a degree. It’s a short term increase that could be a pre tax benefit, or maybe it could be negotiated with local university or college that would help defray the cost and only helps make you more marketable and equitable in your organization, ask for PTO vacation or personal days. Maybe you want Fridays off in the summertime that can be negotiated. Or is there something else in benefits, you know, asking for another percentage increase in a 401, K, or asking for things that don’t necessarily have direct tied to your bottom line, but they are ways that can increase your total package. So, you know, being thoughtful about what do you need or what do you want, and are there ways for the chamber to pay for it as part of your employment, rather than coming out in a paycheck, per se?

Brandon Burton 26:30
Yeah, and I think a lot of these things you wouldn’t necessarily have to feel at the bottom line of a chamber budget, some of these considerations, so I like this, especially the professional development budget, because there’s a lot of different ways to approach that and and ways to advance yourself and in your ability as a as a chamber leader.

Bob Thomas 26:52
Great. I know what’s Yeah, one last one is, if the chamber is not able to afford any additional increases, but they could flex some of your time. Are there creative arrangements that you could make with your board to allow you to do an outside employment opportunity? So are you available to consult? Are you available to do some marketing activity? You know, depending on what your skills are, would the chamber allow you to have some of those outside contracts that would help you supplement your income, that don’t necessarily compete with what the chamber does, but absolutely leverage your skills and give you access to a network that would help you build a side business that can be helpful, especially for people toward the end of their career, where the chamber just isn’t going to grow fast enough for you to see that in your compensation, But it would give you a runway or a launchpad into a post retirement career.

Brandon Burton 27:46
And say, I’ve seen a lot of people do that, that transition towards the end of the career, where they go into a consulting gig or marketing or, you know, some something in that realm, and and I assume with a lot of them, that that may have been a consideration along the way, towards the end of their careers, being able to to start something, because they didn’t necessarily just end their their job at the Chamber one day and then start their consulting gig the next day. Usually, it’s been something that’s kind of been building up, kind of in the background, but gaining some momentum as well. How have you seen that be successful for people making that transition from chamber life to more of the entrepreneur, taking it on on their own towards the end of the career? So

Bob Thomas 28:31
I’ve probably seen it be less successful more often than I’ve seen more successful in the sense that if you aren’t keeping care of the chamber as your first priority while also working on the second option. Things tend to end badly, because then people see that you have divided attention. But if you’re able to have those two things coexist, and you can use the resources of the chamber, and you know also the goodwill of your board to do both, then that works, but you do really have to be thoughtful and know that your first obligation is to the chamber, and then the second is that you can build those other things with strategic PTO, you know, or, you know, leveraging some of the relationship relationships you have with members to get additional referrals. So that’s where I would see it be most successful is when you’re able to keep your eye on both balls at the same time. Yeah,

Brandon Burton 29:31
yeah. That’s that’s a good point. One other thing I wanted to just touch back on you had mentioned, like, if you had a bang up here with with your membership or sponsorships or the certain event that’s driving in revenue to to try to get a portion of that back to as a some sort of a bonus, or, you know, performance related bonus. And in a big sense, that’s it’s sort of found money. You know, if you’re going above and beyond what the expectations were, I mean, every, ideally, every dollar coming in should have a purpose, right? That’s coming in. But if you can benchmark that, or kind of dog your that on the front end, and say, every dollar coming in has its purpose, but above this, this threshold, the purposes shift a little bit, and I get rewarded for the work that’s going in.

Bob Thomas 30:24
I think I’ve seen lots of chamber and sex do a fantastic job, and they end up with the year in the black, and then they’re building this reserve account, and they’ve got a major surplus, but they haven’t ever asked for a bonus. They’re just looking at their salary as the only compensation they bring in. And if you’ve done that great of a job that year and you’ve cleared all those hurdles, that should be the easy ask. It is money that’s waiting to be invested, and why not invest in your staff? Yeah,

Brandon Burton 30:56
absolutely. Well, are there any other considerations that we need to think of before we start to wrap up our conversation.

Bob Thomas 31:06
Just one is, you know when those conversations don’t work out in your favor? When should you start to have conversations with yourself or your family that maybe it is time to go? Because I do know that while we think and hope for the best with our boards or with our bosses. Sometimes the resources just aren’t there, or the recognition that the dollars could be invested as staff isn’t there either. And so maybe that’s the time when you’ve got to think, am I aligned with this work anymore? Is it worth the stress, or, you know, the effort that I’m putting into it is there are there other benefits that I would see outside of the chamber, and those are hard conversations, I know, especially because you love your job, or you love your members, and you love what you do, but there’s always a tipping point when it doesn’t necessarily work in your favor. And so also to have that open and honest conversation with yourself and with your board when the juice isn’t worth the squeeze anymore. And unfortunately, those conversations need to happen as regularly as they do when you’re asking for compensation, just to make sure that there’s alignment there with your personal goals and and know when to say when? Yeah, I

Brandon Burton 32:23
think that’s important to think about. And I, as I’ve seen it with a lot of executives as they exit their career, sometimes it comes back to a board member that they just can’t get along with. They can’t see I die. And rather than waiting out whatever is left in the term for that board member, they just see that as the better options to leave, because they can’t, they can’t make it work together. But it’s a whole nother discussion. And, you know, recruiting your board members to make sure you’ve got people on your board that you can work with and that you can move the ball forward and not have that kind of conflict, so that that’ll lead into a longer term ability at your chamber, if you’re if you’re the executive, if you’re staff, and you can’t get along with your boss, that’s a whole nother story. So Right?

Bob Thomas 33:11
And I would say probably in the most extreme case, and I’ve ran into a couple of chambers since the pandemic, where this has been more common than not, it’s never okay to work for free. So if cash flow has become an issue, or it’s a situation where the board is asking you to defer your compensation or just get through a slow period because of cash flow, in my opinion, that’s never okay. Everybody is worth a paycheck. And to be really thoughtful about, you know, what are the underlying issues that you don’t have cash that would make payroll, and in those particular cases, if they can’t afford you, let alone afford an increase that’s also not worth your time. So make sure that you’re holding your boards and yourself to the standard that you are worth the job of running a chamber is worth a paycheck. So I’m hoping there’s a lot of listeners out there that agree with me, and that nobody out there is not working for free, because that’s, in my opinion, just unacceptable. And I know it happens more often than we know about

Brandon Burton 34:18
Yeah, I 100% endorse that everyone is worth a paycheck. Yes. Well, Bob, as we start to wrap things up here, I like to see if there’s any kind of tip or action item for listeners who are looking to take their organization up to the next level. What would you suggest for them to try to implement to accomplish that goal,

Bob Thomas 34:39
specific around compensation, and, you know, asking for what you’re due or what you’re valued at, I would just say, you know, have an annual conversation with yourself about what’s important to you, what are your priorities, and how do you value those, both personally in terms of your own growth and development. And then also monetarily. What is that worth? What is your time worth to you and your family in order for you to achieve your goals? And then second is to share that and have an open conversation with the people who are making decisions about your compensation, so that you’re aligned. And if you’re not aligned, then you at least know where the line was, because I do find that people who are willing to have those open and honest conversations are more likely to negotiate things that work for everybody than to be denied or catch people by surprise. And so I guess that would be my advice is just to know yourself first and then second. Don’t be afraid to ask for it. Just have that open conversation.

Brandon Burton 35:43
I like it well, as we look to the future of chambers of commerce, how do you see the future of chambers and their purpose going forward?

Bob Thomas 35:52
Well, this is a great time to ask that question, because I know ACCE is about to come out with our horizon 2.0 and I’m really excited about what that could look like for our chambers, in terms of a road map of things that we should be asking about. I find the chamber future to be bright, and I know that there’s a lot of movement and a lot of change right now. We’re seeing a lot of generational impact on what our chambers look like, but I also find that means the chambers that are disciplined to know what they’re all about and what value they bring to their communities, they’re going to find a business model that’s going to make them more relevant than ever. I always say, imagine what your community would look like without a chamber, and you’ve probably driven through it, definitely haven’t stopped in it. And so the chambers that have figured that out, or the communities that have figured that out, are supporting their chambers, and those chambers are vibrant, bright and offering a lot of value to the business community.

Brandon Burton 36:55
Yeah, yeah, I love that. But Bob, I like to ask everyone I have on this show. If there’s a listener who wants to reach out and connect with you, get to learn a little bit more about what we talked about today. What would be the best way, or where would you point them to reach out and connect with you?

Bob Thomas 37:10
Well, the easiest way is definitely through email, at the Michigan chamber B Thomas at MI chamber.com, or happy to connect with folks through my LinkedIn profile. LinkedIn slash Thomas Bob. Double check to make sure that was the right one. Yep,

Brandon Burton 37:31
there’s no other Bob Thomas, right.

Bob Thomas 37:35
There are a ton of Bob Thomas that would be the right Bob Thomas’s. LinkedIn slash Thomas, Bob, and would love to hear from my chamber colleagues, because I’ve worked at the Michigan Chamber for over 27 years, and these are some of my best friends and most valued relationships are in this community. So always glad to hear from them.

Brandon Burton 37:55
Very good. Well, we’ll get that in our show notes, including the LinkedIn, you know, the correct profile in LinkedIn to make it easy and have people find you, but I appreciate you setting aside some time to be with us today on chamber chat podcast and approaching this important topic, I mean it. It really does. It breaks my heart every time I see somebody exit the chamber world or and there’s a lot of different reasons, but when I see the good people leave for the private sector, I’m like, I wish we could keep them in the chamber world a little longer. So being able to have these conversations and hopefully keep some of these good ones in the chamber world as long as they want to be there, I think, is fantastic. So thank you for sharing this with us today.

Bob Thomas 38:38
Thanks for having me. It’s always good to have alumni if you’re not able to stay in the chamber. But I agree. I love working with chamber people, and it’s I’m glad when they’re able to work it out and they can stay.

Brandon Burton 38:50
If you are a chamber professional, please subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast in Apple podcast, Google podcasts or Spotify. When you subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast new episodes will show up in your podcast app each week as they are released. If you’re finding value in this podcast, please leave us a rating and a review in iTunes. But most importantly, please share Chamber Chat Podcast with your colleagues that are in the industry.

Get started with your own Chamber Podcast and shortcut your learning curve with the Chamber Podcast Course offered by Chamber Chat Podcast.
Have you considered the many benefits of hosting a podcast for your Chamber? The options, leverage, and possibilities that a podcast offers are virtually endless. Download my FREE Chamber Podcasting Guide to learn how to start your own Chamber podcast!