I am going to start this article with a disclaimer that I realize you may have personal thoughts, concerns, or prejudices towards NTFs and cryptocurrencies. I also understand that some of these terms may be completely foriegn to you. In this article, I will try to explain some of these trending technologies in terms that are easy to understand. I also want to encourage you to read this article with an open mind to maybe gain a better view of the direction the business world may be heading.
Over the past five year or so, I have been learning more about Bitcoin, crypto currencies, and more recently NFTs or non-fungible tokens. As I started this education, I have learned a lot and my thoughts on these technologies have evolved over time and will likely continue to evolve along with these associated ecosystems. I will also mention that the ideas that I will share in this article are very much to help you prepare for the future, not that you have to run and do anything about it today.
My Introduction to Bitcoin
So, let me backup my story to around 2010 when Bitcoin first hit my radar. I remember sitting in my car in Seguin, TX listening to the radio and the radio host was talking about how someone had just bought a Papa John’s pizza, just a large pizza for 10,000 Bitcoin. That was a news headline that day because it is the first time that we saw a real utility for Bitcoin. Still at the time, the guy at the pizza shop probably paid for the pizza out of his pocket and kept the Bitcoin because nobody really understood what Bitcoin was or what it could do. Fast forward to today’s price for Bitcoin, that was about a $300,000,000 pizza! Compare that to the previous high for Bitcoin, that price tag would have been $690,000,000! I guess that’s why they say hindsight is 20/20.
My next exposure to Bitcoin I believe was around 2014 when I was listening to a podcast about investing and the current price of Bitcoin was mentioned to be around $4,000. I was in shock. I could not believe anyone would pay that much for a digital coin that didn’t have any real utility. This did peak my interest though so I started to learn more about Bitcoin and why people would pay so much to own it.
Boost your Chamber’s efficiency & revenues with digital certification of origin and movement documents, powered by essCert – the leading choice for 400 Chambers & 50,000+ satisfied Chamber members.
The more I learned, the more it intrigued me. I learned that the creator of Bitcoin is anonymous and once Bitcoin was launched, he/she/they disappeared. This means that Bitcoin is a decentralized monetary system. There is no company headquarters. There is no person to be subpoenaed if someone has a grievance. Instead, there are 1) Bitcoin miners who are competing with other miners by completing complicated mathematical problems to then be rewarded with Bitcoin, 2) individual nodes on the Bitcoin network which validate transactions on the open blockchain ledger. I also learned that in the code for Bitcoin, there will only ever be 21 million in circulation. This is done through programming and the rewards to miners. So there is a fixed supply, and nobody has the authority or ability to create more.
Because of these traits, Bitcoin is often referred to as digital gold as a store of value or a hedge against inflation. However, unlike gold, Bitcoin is easily sent to the other side of the world almost instantaneously. Bitcoin also established what is known as the blockchain which is the technology that all other crypto currencies operate with.
Many other crypto currencies have since spun off from the initial creation of Bitcoin, each with different purposes and utilities. One of the most popular is Etherium which is known for it’s smart contract feature. However there are others such as Solana.
I mention these other crypto currencies because they are often used to transact NFTs.
What is an NFT?
An NFT is a non-fungible token. This means that it is a digital token with unique characteristics that cannot be duplicated, thus giving unique rights of ownership. If you think of a dollar bill, they are essentially all the same. If I asked you to hand me a dollar bill, I don’t care if it is the one in the front of your wallet, or the one in the back, or the one in your pocket, or from your junk drawer, they are all the same and carry the same value. An NFT, there is only one of a kind, each with a unique value.
In an effort to show utility for NFTs, the early adoption was with digital art. A creator or artist can publish or “mint” their art as an NFT and whoever purchases the NFT would be the authentic owner of that art. For me, there were too many holes with this example for me to grasp onto and I quickly dismissed the value of an NFT utility. Then I heard of some examples that caught my interest much like Bitcoin did back in 2014. Think of the title of your home, there is only one, and you are the owner of it. That could easily become an NFT and rather than purchasing title insurance, the owner of the NFT is verified on the blockchain network. I know, as I explain this, that seems like it is really far in the future, and maybe it is but it is coming. The same is true for a drivers license or any government issued ID. They could be issued as an NFT that you keep in your crypto wallet.
As I continued to digest what I was learning about NFTs, I was looking for other ways an NFT could be applied. I heard of Gary Vaynerchuk. Gary is a podcaster, wine seller, and social media influencer. During the pandemic, Gary started an NFT project called VeeFriends. The way it works is Gary minted over 10,000 doodles of different animals such as Passionate Parrot. Each NFT in addition to the art (which was not very special) you also gained access to Gary. Some of the NFTs also gave you 30 minutes of business consulting with Gary, dinner with Gary, or a game of chess with Gary. Gary also promised to hold an annual conference for the holders of his NFT and the NFT serves as your ticket to the conference.
Directories, magazines, maps, and digital… Consider Community Matters, Inc. for your next chamber publication.
Since launching VeeFriends, Gary has continued to “airdrop” more assets and value to his NFT holders. There is also a healthy aftermarket for NFTs and because they are bought and sold within the Etherium smart contract network, Gary earns a 10% royalty on every resale of his NFTs.
How NFTs Can Be Utilized
When I heard about VeeFriends, my mind began to wonder and to explore other NFT uses. I was working on a Chamber Podcast Course at the time I learned about VeeFriends. I had the thought of launching my course as an NFT essentially to give access to the course. My thought was if I only had 10 NFTs for my course, once a chamber took the course and learned how to podcast, they no longer have a need for it. Why not allow them to resell the course to another chamber. This would allow for the first chamber to recover their investment after they got the value they needed, and then they would have motivation to resell and essentially market the course to other chambers and I could get a royalty for the ongoing resells of the course. Great idea right? I think it was a great idea, a couple years too early…
That led me to think about chambers in general. As a membership organization, it is all about providing access to information, events, opportunities, products, etc. Why not bundle these offerings into a tiered dues type of NFT project? Because they are based on smart contracts, if a business were to move, they could sell their membership and you would get a commission or royalty. Your ambassadors could purchase multiple NFTs and sell them to other businesses. The NFT would be their ticket to your annual meeting, luncheons, trainings, etc. Businesses could purchase multiple NFTs for other staff members. You could set the terms within the smart contract for how long the NFT was good for, 1 year, 2 years, etc. I hope this is giving you some ideas.
As the idea of NFTs for membership continues to evolve, we could see a time where a DAO could be set up. A DAO is a decentralized autonomous organization. Essentially, this DAO could function as a board of directors. The options are limitless. However, timing is everything. At this stage, I believe education is key. Do what you can to learn about crypto currency, Bitcoin, and NFTs. Play with some “live ammo” or in other words make some small purchases to see how these things work so you know how to educate your members as the time comes.
Again, the purpose of this article is not for you to stop the way you are doing things and to make a hard pivot, but rather as Wayne Gretsky says skate to where the puck is headed rather than where it is.
If you would like to start playing in the crypto world, I do have an affiliate link for Coinbase which would give you and I both $10 worth of Bitcoin if you use the link provided.
Please join our email list to receive new blog posts are they are released. You will stay in the loop with any announcements related to the podcast or the Chamber world in general.
Be sure you are subscribed to Chamber Chat Podcast in your favorite podcast app. Subscribers are the first to get episodes as new ones come out each week.
Below is an auto-generated transcription of my conversation with Sara Ray. Because this is auto-generated there are likely some grammatical errors but it is still a useful tool to search text within this podcast episode.
Feel free to join our Chamber Chat Champions Facebook Group to discuss this episode and to share your own experiences and tips with other Chamber Champions.
This is the Chamber Chat Podcast, the show dedicated to chamber professionals to spark ideas and to get actionable tips and strategies to better serve your members and community.
Voiceover Talent 0:14
And now, your host…He encourages chambers to collect quality data so they can better segment their lists.
He’s my dad Brandon Burton.
Brandon Burton 0:23
Hello, Chamber Champions. Welcome to Chamber Chat Podcast. I’m your host Brandon Burton, where it is my goal to introduce you to people and ideas to better help you serve your Chamber members and your community.
Well, Doug and Bill at the Holman Brothers have been a key ally in growth for my professional career working at three different chambers, a local chamber, a regional chamber and now a statewide chamber. And they’ve been the ideal solution, whether it’s a comprehensive training program, whether it’s working on individual sales growth, quarterly check ins with the team, the ability to grow members has meaning more assets for the organization, more assets means we can do more things to serve our members. They’ve really been the perfect solution for us, a trusted resource partner and a growth partner for us all along the way. So hats off to Doug and Bill for their great success. They’ll be a great partner for you as they are for us.
Brandon Burton 1:31 You can learn more about Holman Brothers Membership Sales Solutions by visiting HolmanBros.com.
Doug & Bill Holman know how to diagnose and solve member recruiting issues faster and better than anyone else, and they want to put that knowledge to work for you and your chamber. Learn more at HolmanBros.com.
Guest Introduction
Our guest for this episode is Sara Ray. Sara became the president and CEO of the Douglas County Chamber in April 2018. Sara has more than 15 years of chamber corporate and nonprofit leadership experience including UPS Yancey bros as Strayer University, the Cultural Arts Council of Douglas, and four positions at the Douglas County Chamber. Sara serves on the Regional Business coalition executive committee is Vice Chair for the WellStar Douglas hospital regional board, and as a founding partner in Elevate Douglas economic partnership, a public private partnership created in 2021. She also serves on the board of the Georgia Association of Chamber of Commerce executives Georgia Academy of economic development, Cobb and Douglas public health steering committee and founding member of keep Douglas County beautiful. Sara received her Georgia certified chamber executive designation in 2021, making her one of only 22 in the history of the organization. She is a graduate of the US Chamber institutes of organizational management in 2015, the US Chamber business leads fellowship Regional Leadership Institute, Georgia forward young game changer, leadership Douglas and is it active in these alumni associations. In 2019, Sara was named by Georgia Secretary of State as outstanding Georgia citizen. She was also named as the West Georgia livings 40 under 40 in 2019, and a top 10 Young Professional in Douglas in 2015 and 2017. Her service to the community does not go unnoticed. She was recognized as Volunteer of the Year for the Georgia Ovarian Cancer Alliance in 2010 and 2012 Spirit Award by the city of Douglasville, Sara received her bachelor’s from the University of North Carolina Wilmington. When she isn’t working to support businesses and Douglas in the metro Atlanta region. Sara spends her time traveling and being outdoors with their children, Anna and Avery. Sarah, I’m excited to have you with me today on Chamber Chat Podcast, we will take a moment to say hello to all the Chamber Champions and share something interesting about yourself so we can get to know you a little bit better.
Sara Ray 3:53
Yeah, well, thank you for having me today. I have thought long and hard about this question. But I think something interesting about me is while I was born and raised in Georgia, my parents are both from overseas. So I’m a first generation American. And my dad is from England and my mom is from South Africa. So a lot of times when people meet me they see you know, cute little you know, southern girl and they don’t realize you know that my summers were spent in Africa and in the wild so so it’s it’s people always kind of that’s kind of throws them off.
Brandon Burton 4:31
So you get together with your family to get a variety of accents going on.
Sara Ray 4:34
Yes, yes. My mom always joke that like when I was in preschool, I came home and the first time I said y’all, she just cried because I had a British accent until I went to school because that was all I ever heard. So
Brandon Burton 4:48
yeah, it’s funny. I can just see that British accent you know, saying Yo she’s like, where did my baby go? Well tell us about the Douglas County Chamber just to give us some perspective, maybe size budget staff, that sort of thing
About the Douglas County Chamber
Sara Ray 5:06
before we get us. Yes. So our chamber is 77 years old. We have about 650 members that are investors in our organization. And we are located in west, west, just west of Atlanta, we’re about 20 miles west. So we are considered the Metro Atlanta region, but still kind of close enough. We always say, you know, close enough to the city to be able to catch a baseball game with our, you know, world champion, Atlanta Braves. But also, we still have plenty of green space and amenities where we can explore and enjoy the outdoors. So yes, so our team we are, we have and we have an interesting kind of space, we are in the process of integrating staff with our economic development organization elevate Douglas, so we share staff, but our full team is about 12 Strong between both organizations. But as far as chamber employees, we have about eight, so I think it was there anything I missed?
Brandon Burton 6:02
No, I think that that pretty much covers it. And so it sounds like you’ve said that before. Yeah. how close you are to Atlanta. And notice you you mentioned Braves and the Falcons but that that’s okay.
Sara Ray 6:17
We got we got UGA we’ve been
Brandon Burton 6:20
you gotta get your highlights, right. Yeah.
Sara Ray 6:22
Falcons fan. I know. I still have like, you know, wounds from five ish years ago. But yeah, yeah. Yeah. We’ll definitely talk about the Braves all day long.
Brandon Burton 6:32
That’s right. That’s right. So as we get into our topic for discussion, today, we’re gonna focus our conversation around creating relevant and personalized communication, which I think is going to be something relevant for listeners as we try to figure out the best ways to communicate with not only our members but people in the community and really, you know, be in that that voice for business community. So I’m excited to get into this discussion with you as soon as we get back from this quick break.
Are you looking for a year round affordable and timely shop local campaign for your chamber or CVB Look no further build a custom each shop play mobile app with App My Community by visiting appmycommunity.com/chamberchat. App My Community mobile apps are not just simple membership directory listings. They provide many more capabilities to engage with your community. Provide your residents with a robust events calendar partner with a local fare festival or Farmers Market provide a schedule map and other resources to promote the event. Run a Small Business Saturday campaign any time of the year using built in scavenger hunts allow your membership to communicate directly to their customers via push notifications. Your app my community mobile app will be a unique member benefit allow you to generate non dues revenue with sponsorship opportunities and best of all provide a valuable resource to your community please visit appmycommunity.com/chamberchat now to receive 10% off your first year of an App My Community mobile app.
App My Community creates mobile apps that allow you to engage directly with your community. Enhance chamber membership by providing a unique advertising and communication channel to residents and visitors. Not just a member directory, App My Community has the tools to be useful to residents on a daily basis. Learn more at appmycommunity.com/chamberchat.
Chambers of Commerce have been around for over 400 years promoting communities all over the World. But today so much is found digitally that Chamber Nation believes it’s critical that there is a custodian of local digital information. They believe the Chamber is in a perfect position to be that organization.
Chamber Nation provides an amazing membership management system you use to manage the chamber and the community. They also deliver a complete membership development system that they manage for you to be sure your membership community is fully documented for search and much more. Essentially, Chamber Nation delivers an entire membership support department which is perfect for those Chambers with a limited budget that needs to do more.
With Chamber Nation not only will you have a membership management system but also a membership development system all in one terrific package. So, SAVE MONEY and be impressed by visiting www.RichardsCalendar.com to set up a demo with their CEO. Or learn more at www.ChamberNation.com.
All right, Sara, we’re back. As I mentioned before the break, we’re talking about communication, creating relevant and personalized communication. I’d love to hear what you guys are doing there at the Douglas County Chamber to do this. Yeah, you know, what, what spurred the thought for this to be the focus of our discussion.
Sara Ray 9:36
Yeah, so I think it’s probably best to start up I’m gonna say the beginning. You know, I’ve been at the chamber as, as you mentioned, for just around 12 years and took over SEO about four years ago. So I felt like I’ve seen a lot of different things and you know, experience different trends and marketing and communications. That was actually the role I started out in being at the chamber so then seeing it grow and evolve. But I would say the beginning of our journey to where we’re at now and how we have moved into a space of having more customized personal communications was like a lot of people during the pandemic. So, you know, as a, an organization that was primarily in person with our events, that leaned into that space we were very accustomed to, like, I would assume a lot of chambers are is casting a net at, you know, at all your businesses, you know, the more people the merrier in a room, you know, that that equated to a successful event. And that was very, very true with myself in spaces, but also with my team. So when we had to go into an environment where we couldn’t do face to face, or, you know, we were just trying to still cast that net, but not being able to have those one on one conversations, we knew we had to do something different. So I remember specifically, we had brought back, and it was probably like late 2021 of our after hours events, it was outside, you know, open air. And I remember, in our, in our after hours, events typically have about 75 to 125 people, this one, there were about 27 or 28 people, and my team was coming up to me, this is a failure, this is not great. This is you know, we’ve lost our you know, our our mojo, this is awful. And I just remember being like, you guys are missing the big picture, look around the room and see what is happening, I said people are able to not come into a space where they don’t know anybody, you know, or they feel uncomfortable or overwhelmed, because of the number of people that are there. I said, people are able to come in and have a conversation, they aren’t worried about working the room. And and you know, getting as many business cards out as, as they can, they’re able to sit and have actual conversations. And I was a perfect example of that. I mean, as, as our viewers probably know, chamber execs you’re out work in the room, making sure that everybody feels welcome and included. And I remember sitting down with one of our youth leadership students, high school junior, and having like a 10 minute conversation on their career path and their trajectory, and all of these different you know, like just actually getting to know them. And, and that was a conversation I had with my team. And I was I was like you guys are missing the big picture, like people are having more authentic intentional interactions with one another. And that fosters a relationship and a depth of depth to a relationship that we can’t touch. Like we can’t, we can’t touch that in an email or communication, not the way we’re set up right now. So we ended up working with an organization to do again. So we kind of looked at, we started shifting some our events, instead of being a catch all for everyone. And during the business after hours, we had targeted industries that we were networking with, we had, you know, different themes. So we started a minority business group, we started a women in business group. So we started out with our events, but then what we realized quickly was, how are we getting the information out to everyone in a way that they can, that it that it resonates with them, and that they find value in that. So we went through the process of doing a marketing communications analysis and looked at all of the different things that we were doing email, social website, how we were how people were getting the information, and that was members, and it was non members. So we were polling and surveying our business community at large. And one of the things that kind of came back to all of it was that people don’t like getting the emails that are that are sent to the droves, you know, email was definitely their number one choice for how they wanted to be communicated with and this is in my community could look different. But even with the way that you interact with people on social media, like it’s great that we were posting, you know, we had a content calendar, and we were posting something on wherever, every other day, and we had a process behind that. But people wanted the engagement, they wanted to see themselves they wanted, you know, they wanted to know the stories about people so so we’ve gone through the process of customizing how we communicate with our businesses looking at we’ve created like a preference center. So you know, what Brandon might want contact information on it might be leadership and events and I might want information on policy and economic development. So we’ve created a you know, an infrastructure in our in our communications and how we do our events, that it’s customized and catered to the individuals just so that’s kind of the high level, how we got there. So
Brandon Burton 14:30
I love this. I just in fact, it was a week or two ago, I actually wrote and shared out a blog post about this very thing. Well, when you’re talking about these mixers, it was about that very thing. It’s like you know, so many people show up at a mixer. They’re new to the chamber, right? They show up, got a pocket full of business cards, or they’re gonna get their drink and they stand there totally awkward. Yeah, they don’t know anybody. And then you know, 10 minutes later they leave because Yeah, nothing happens that they’re super uncomfortable and That’s one of the huge value propositions, you know, for joining the chambers and networking. Yeah. Well, if it doesn’t resonate for them, they have a bad experience at first time, how likely are they to come back. So being able to have these personalized, you know, relevant events for them to attend, and really make sure that they resonate with not only the topic, but the other people that are there. So it makes sense to communicate with them.
Sara Ray 15:24
Yeah. And it’s not just about like getting them to the event, it’s the before and after to like, we’ve incorporated pieces into the process where, when they register, it’s, Hey, thanks for registering. And it’s all automated through chambermaster. You know, and it just says, Thanks for registering before you get here, check out our speakers, and we have links to the bios, and then two days before they get an email that’s like, you know, get excited, these are things that we’re going to have here, if we have kind of upcoming announcements or things you need to know before you get there. And then on the backside, we have follow up emails that are thanks for joining, here’s the pictures, here’s the links to whomever was speaking, you know, share your experience, and we put in there literally a copy and paste of post this on so on your LinkedIn, and they just have to drop it in there. So it gives them a good way to engage with us outside of just the event. And we you know, we’ll put in there register for our next event. So it’s all about creating, we call it an engagement pathway. So it’s all about creating that it’s not ever a start to finish. It’s always the what’s next behind things. So
Brandon Burton 16:27
so how do you go about in your, in your database to segment your lists? You’d mentioned you know, what their interests are I, the way I’ve envisioned it is you have a conversation of sorts, and in some of these, you probably have to guess if they’ve been a member forever, and maybe they’re not super high, you need to make some guesses. But as you onboard a new member to be able to have a discussion of what’s your expectation from the chain? What are you joining for? Is that how you guys go about it? Or what does that look like to be able to Yes,
Sara Ray 16:59
I’m going to call I’m going to call it bite sized pieces, I’m getting an email about like this long, you know, like, four pages long, is very inundating and overwhelming for someone. So we’ve actually shifted to I would call it like a drip campaign. So when they get their first email, it’s, you know, Hey, welcome to the chamber, we’re so excited to have you, here’s your login, be on the lookout, we have this next thing coming up, your next email will be about XYZ and then the next email that they get is, hey, we want to learn more about you. Right, so talk to us about the things that interested you in joining the chamber. And we capture some of that through our member application. But then it’s getting more into the space of what did they as the primary contact one, the next email is, hey, tell us about your team, let’s make sure and add in anybody that you have that as a part of your team that we need to include in our conversations, because, again, Sara raise preferences, and Julia in my office, it might be different. And the things that they find value in as a member would be different. So we’ve shifted instead of it just being this one dump of information into small videos and and kind of little snippets, that cycle out, I would say at least once a week for the first month, and then we kind of lag it out a little bit. But that way, it gives them the information kind of on a consistent basis without overwhelming them. Because that was another thing people don’t want to read through, like I said, five pages of information. So we’ve we’ve just shifted to that kind of little bite sized piece of information. And then there’s some other things, we mail them some stuff too. So they’re getting that attention, we send we have somebody that does a phone call. So we have a whole process in place. But yeah, identifying their specific needs and interests, we do that some through the main contact through when they apply. But then it’s part of the process. And we just capture that through our CRM. And then we actually connect it into the campaign system that we use for email marketing. So and then you can go into if we’re getting super granular, like the tags and segments within your email marketing system. So then you can go through and kind of pick and choose and say, hey, I want to send this piece of information to people who are tagged that they like information about women in leadership, or it could be about policy. So we kind of lean on those different tools to to segment it out, because there is information you want everybody to get and know about your big signature event or your upcoming event or training that you have. But then some of the information, you know, might not be relevant to you know, a solopreneur that’s never that doesn’t need to hire anybody doesn’t necessarily need to have all the information on how to post a job on our on our job site. So yeah, it’s just trying to try to funnel down and fine tune that information to where it’s what they find this value in. And then you can track it all on the back end through analytics and see again, and we drive almost all of our activity, I would say all of it to our website so that we can track the analytics and know where people are going, what information that they’re actually likely looking at and learning from.
Brandon Burton 19:54
I love that and I think this is going to be one of those episodes that people go back and listen to or at least You know those last few minutes? Like, okay, take notes, and how did you do this step to the next day? So, simple question, what, what email platform do you guys use?
Sara Ray 20:11
Yes. So, we have tried a few, we use Constant Contact for a long, long time. I know as chamber people, we get it for free, which is great, but I and I mean, contact is wonderful. But there are other paid platforms that can give you more. So we actually investigated using Campaign Monitor, but then ended up going with MailChimp. So it integrates with chambermaster, which is our CRM that we use. So and has a lot of capabilities and even the visibility, the open rates are better with MailChimp than some of the others just because they don’t automatically pop into your junk folder and things like that. So we have some great partners that we work with, that are investors with the chamber that helped us kind of work through all that process, it wasn’t, you know, I don’t have a crystal ball. And I will say to that doesn’t mean what works for us will work for everyone. And Constant Contact has does have some great tools that are associated with it, if you’re on a little bit of a tighter budget, but that was we ended up moving forward with MailChimp was what we ended up going with.
Brandon Burton 21:11
So and I wanted to highlight that just so listeners when they talk about when they hear you talk about segmenting tags, and all these things like, Well, my software doesn’t do that, or where do you find that? So it’s within MailChimp that you’re doing those things. Yeah. So I love the way that you go about with that kind of introductory email, you know, here’s some things to look forward to. And then the follow up as to, you know, what kind of things are of interest to you? Where do you do you see, as people, you know, have a longer time with the chamber with their membership or investment where they learn about new offerings that the Chamber has and to be able to add that to their interest. So they’re getting those those pieces of information? How do you add that in along their membership journey,
Sara Ray 21:59
oh, you’re gonna laugh at this one, we have a nickname for how we do that in my office. So um, you know, we’ve used MailChimp for a lot of our you know, we use that for our I would say standard, we do a top five email that goes out on Mondays, you know, we have social that we post we did videos, those kind of things. If we are in a space, and we want again, because a lot of people just see chamber emails, and they’re like, Oh, I’m just gonna keep clicking through. So what we learned, and I honestly don’t remember how we got into the space. My team calls them, Hey, friend emails. And it’s literally me, emailing our entire database through chambermaster. And I write them just like it’s coming from, I mean, it is coming from me, but I read it just like I’m emailing you directly. And the tone and the language behind it is just as if I was writing to any, you know, any of my businesses that are members. And it’s, Hey, how are you very generic entry. Hey, there, and it’s, you know, I always try and make some kind of interesting subject line, like, got a second or one quick thing for you. And then I go into, hey, hope you’re doing great. Getting ready for the weekend, or whatever, you know, whatever, just some kind of little intro, but like, I just wanted to make sure, I don’t know if you saw the emails, but I want to make sure you knew about XYZ event or training or whatever that we’re doing. That’s coming up, I think it might be great for you. You know, we’d love to hear your thoughts on that. And we’d love to see, see your face at it. If it was an event or whatever. If there’s anything that you need from me, you know, I’m always here, have a great day. And I literally, that’s basically what are our response rate? And people like people have no idea? Well, some of them start picking up on it, they have no idea that it’s sent to 1000s of people. So I get responses from people. They’re like, Oh, my gosh, it’s been so long since we talked hope you’re doing well, thanks for checking on me, you know, so we call it Hey, friend emails in my office. And that’s a great way because then we’re able to go back. And if I get an email from someone, like I said, that I haven’t heard from in a long time or haven’t seen an event, and they’re responding to an event that we’re talking about, you know, going to our cap the state capitol, then I know that that’s piqued their interest in some space, if they’re choosing to respond to me, Hey, I hope I can make it please keep sending me the this this way, you know, would love to have this in a virtual format like we get we I get honestly I get better open rates on those than any other email platform that I do. And again, nobody knows what I mean. A few again, a few now know the secret, but for the most part, but that’s the bottom comes in. I have to be so let my team is there. There’ll be like, can you send a hey, for an email? I was like, I’ve already sent one this week. Like we’ve got to limit or they lose their hour. But yeah, so yeah, so Hey, friend, emails work really well. I actually had one of our state our congressional senators offices call me she’s like, I need to set up a meeting with you. She goes are those emails like really to everyone? Or is it just to me, because she said she forwards them out to her team every time and it’s like This is how we need to communicate with our business, you know, with our constituents, and it started as a random thing, but that’s kind of our, our secret sauce that you know, we have our templated emails. But if we need to pull a friend one out, then it works almost every time.
Brandon Burton 25:16
And I imagine that those Hey, friend emails are also going to help with your open rates and deliverability of the emails going out through MailChimp to see that those are getting delivered and opened and responded to, they’re gonna deliver more of those inboxes. Exactly. That’s, that’s awesome. But then, so you’re taking those manually those responses and saying this members interested in this and then updating their profile
Sara Ray 25:39
that, yeah, I have somebody on my team that I’ll just forward them to. And it’s also a great way to make sure we have bad emails that are coming through or bounces or changes in role, you know, because there’s lovely member info updates that we all try and send are only so successful before we have to get on the phone. So this is a good kind of consistent way to kind of work through that process. Yeah.
Brandon Burton 25:59
So one of the other things he had mentioned, I want to make sure that I understood it, right. It sounds like one of those follow up emails and member first joins is saying who else in your organization would be interested in XYZ. So you’re, you’re getting other contact information for each business, but then also able to further the segmentation to that person’s over HR versus, you know, over, you know, the CEO, as the company, they’re going to be, you have different interests, so you’re able to touch them on different levels at the same
Sara Ray 26:31
business. And I was trying to add something, we always add some language like, if this isn’t for you, please feel free to share with share it with somebody, you know, and make sure a lot of people and I know that you’ve heard this before, but they think that they’re the only person that’s a member of their chamber. I’ve had several conversations with our school district. I’m like, every teacher, every educator is a member of the chamber. So you know, like, use that leverage that leverage that bandwidth. Oh, yeah.
Brandon Burton 26:57
Yeah, no, I think that’s key. Yeah. They think whoever was the one that signed up to chat. Yeah, right. Yeah. Oh, crazy. Yeah. Or just the owner. But yeah, it can. And obviously, every chamber is a little different. But most chambers that I’m aware of is opened it. Yeah, buddy within their business. So good point. I think this topic is so important. I’ve mentioned this a few times. And I think it’s worth mentioning again, just with the topic is my background is in chamber publishing says I would go out and meet with different Chamber members. And they find out that I’m not actually with the chamber, but they open up to me. Yeah. It’s like, I’m a bartender, and they just start telling me, you know, this is this last experience, this last event was awesome. Or I get way too many emails from the chamber. You know, I’ll ask them, Did
Sara Ray 27:46
you get to see my, like, little chamber therapist?
Brandon Burton 27:48
Exactly. They’re like, I get so many emails from the chamber. I probably got it. But you know, yeah, I deleted or I just opened it moved on. So yeah, being able to segment make it highly personable, I think it’s so important. And that’s, that’s the age we’re in today. Anyway, I mean, if you’re just doing a blanket email, there’s, there’s a purpose for it, you know, at times, but if that’s your only communications, a blanket email, you’re missing the boat, and you’re missing opportunities to connect with members. So yeah,
Sara Ray 28:17
and our ultimate goal is to, for people to have value in what we do, right? Like the end game is for someone to say that they got what they were looking for out of their membership. And if you have simple tools in place to be able to pinpoint that so a year in you can say, Hey, you said you wanted information on policy, or you wanted us to go to bat for you, as the voice of business in our community, you can go back on that and say, You, this was what you you know, this is what you said you find value in here. Here is how we took that, like, let’s talk about that. So being heard is so important for businesses.
Brandon Burton 28:52
How do you use the information that you get? I’m calling it segmenting, just for maybe lack of a better term? How do you use that information to create content or plan future events? Do you ever look into it to weigh that into what you’re doing?
Sara Ray 29:08
Oh, absolutely. Yes. I mean, so think of Okay, so we’ve had events, okay. Our breakfast series is a great example. So we used to have a, you know, you know, just a networking breakfast. It was just putting people in a room together. And that was it. Like there was no agenda. I mean, we will get up give door prizes, you know, that normal kind of, Hey, everyone, thanks for coming. And we shifted that and based off of feedback from people saying, you know, what are you doing for minority owned businesses? Why can we have women’s programming we’ve done you know, we did surveys and focus groups talked with our board, of course, and then we’re able to create those events and then solicit feedback on Did you like this, what did you think? And then just continue to craft our programming to meet the needs of our members? You know, we’re a member driven organization as all chambers should be, and so meeting the needs of what our business is our and that looks very different than two years ago, it looks very different than 10 years ago. So just continuing, you know, I am, I am always a proponent of new and different, and sometimes I think exhausts my team. But at the same time, the things that were relevant, you know, three or four years ago are very different. Now, we were never in a space where we thought we’d be relying on Zoom to do, you know, a majority of our work for six or eight months, so. So I think just being open minded and nimble listening to your members, and then and then being okay with adapting and changing, you don’t have to go and completely rebrand your whole organization, you can do it in small spaces, do a beta test of something, try it out, see if people like it, get their feedback. And then you can look at expanding that. So we do a lot in that space of trying things with small groups of people before we pull it into a larger space.
Brandon Burton 30:49
Yeah. And I think as you gather that information on what their expectations are, as they join the chamber, you’re able to then speak their language. And then when it comes time to renew memberships, it’s very hard for them to say, you know, the Chamber didn’t do anything for me, I didn’t see any value out of the chair, if you’re sending them those direct communications and talking to them in exactly what they’re looking for. So yeah, I hope everyone’s taking notes. Yeah, and
Sara Ray 31:15
I think you one more thing, because you asked me about like sharing information, articles and things that you’re what we’ve what we do is we do a lot of alcohol, like inbound marketing. So sharing resources, I’ve always been a firm believer, we don’t have to be the doer of all things, or the creator of all things. So we have a huge focus on building partnerships with other organizations. So we have a great partnership with the Georgia Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, right? We have, I’m going to call it a language barrier with dealing with our Hispanic business community, they are successful at that. So why would we sit and recreate the wheel in bringing that into the mix. So we have a lot of content that we gather from our members, subject matter experts, we partner with our colleges and universities, you know, they’ve great economists that work at colleges and universities, why not lean on them to do our economic development reports and things of that nature. So I think that that’s very important. Even with trainings and professional development opportunities for businesses, you don’t have to create things. It’s it’s even thought more highly of if you partner with others, so we have gone that direction. Our new our new tagline is where partnerships and businesses thrive, because that’s the environment that we try to create. So it’s a lot easier to than trying to recreate the wheel on things.
Brandon Burton 32:27
That’s right. I love that. So as we start to wrap up here, I wanted to ask you what might be one tip or action item for chamber champion listening that they could do at their chamber to help take them up to the next level?
Action Item/Tip for Chamber Champions
Sara Ray 32:40
Yes, um, so I would say, and this is a super simple Hey, friend, email that basically anybody can send out is send an email out, I did this, I tried to do it about once a year. But send out an email to your membership and from from your executive, or whomever you deem that you think would have the baby could even be your board chair, and ask them how you what, you know, kind of three questions What what are you getting from us that you love? What are some things that you need from us? And what can we do differently? You know, and just get that feedback from them. It doesn’t have to be this highly calculated survey. And again, if you go with that personal approach of how can I best support you? I guarantee I remember the first time I did, I got like, 300 emails back and I was inundated, but took the time to respond. And because it was coming from me, it wasn’t again, this, it doesn’t have to be this robust, well thought out process, just zap out an email, ask them how they’re doing how you can best support is there anything I can do to support your business? And you’ll be amazed at the results that you get, it’s super simple, but I promise you, like people find value in that kind of thing.
Brandon Burton 33:47
Absolutely. lets them be heard. Yeah, yes, that’s awesome. Then you
Sara Ray 33:51
can just make a list. And then you know, and you have your marching orders for the things that you can look at adapting and changing. So yeah, and listen and listen to them. And share that information back with your members is also important. Don’t just take it all and keep it in a dropbox folder somewhere, share out with people what, what, you know what your membership is saying. So,
Brandon Burton 34:09
for sure. So as we look to the future, how do you see the future chambers and their purpose going forward?
Future of Chambers
Sara Ray 34:18
Oh, um, you know, I’m sure you’ve chatted with my buddy Casey Steinbacher. Before. She is a great friend of mine. And, you know, she preaches a lot about going from being relevant to being essential. And I think that and I have others that have kind of lived in that space. And I feel like that’s the environment. The things that we have done in the past, as far as chambers go, you know, think 30 years ago, chambers used to be the place that did parades and you know, they might have done ribbon cuttings every now and then. And now we have chambers that are moving the needle in Washington DC advocating on behalf of businesses and helping businesses stay afloat, you know, during the pandemic. So I think I think where I see it going is just continuing to move into that space of being essential. And that looks different for every community. And for every business. You know, during the pandemic, I had a business that was it, they it’s like a kind of like a farm of like a petting zoo farm. And she needed to feed the alpacas on her farm. And the only way she raised revenue to do that was by having visitors and she couldn’t. So helping her figure out what was essential to her helped her us be essential to her. Does that make sense? So. So I think that where we’re headed is into a space of, I mean, it sounds silly, but it’s a space of humanity, it’s listening to people, it’s talking to them. It’s providing a space where they can have those open, honest, intentional conversations, whether that’s about diversity, or whether that’s about you know, growing a company, I think it’s just giving people that personalized attention, where they feel that there is not another option than to be a part of the chamber. I think that that’s kind of the direction that we’re headed in. And that looks different for every business, and it looks different for every community. Yeah, it’s been open to that, too, is important.
Brandon Burton 36:07
I love that you brought up Casey, and in her book, you know, relevant to essential. And if anybody hasn’t read it, it’s a it’s an e book. So look it up on Amazon. terrific book, but I mean, she talks about being relevant to your members becoming essential to your community, which really changes perspective, as you read through the book and read, you know, see the ideas that she shares in there. Yeah, changes perspective. So thank you for that. What would be the best way for a listener to reach out and connect with you if they have any questions about, you know, how you’re doing things their communication wise, or they couldn’t keep up with what’s the best way to reach out,
Connect with Sara Ray
Sara Ray 36:48
I get excited, and I talk fast. So I would say the easiest way is on LinkedIn. And it’s just my LinkedIn profile, you can search at Sara Ray. You can also get to us through our very snazzy new chamber website. It’s DouglasCountyGeorgia.com. Or I’m happy to share my information with you. It’s ray@douglascountygeorgia.com is my email where you can look you can look me up anywhere.
Brandon Burton 37:14
That’s right. And we’ll get all your contact information in the show notes for this episode, which will be at ChamberChatPodcast.com/episode166. But Sarah, thank you so much for joining me today and talking to all the Chamber Champions about this great work that you’re doing and really moving your your chamber forward with your communication channels, and really being more essential to the businesses in your community. I appreciate that.
Sara Ray 37:40
Absolutely. Thank you for having me.
Brandon Burton 37:43
Brandon Burton 33:56 If you are a chamber professional, please subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast in Apple podcast, Google podcasts or Spotify. When you subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast new episodes will show up in your podcast app each week as they are released. If you’re finding value in this podcast, please leave us a rating and a review in iTunes. But most importantly, please share Chamber Chat Podcast with your colleagues that are in the industry.
Click here for a FREE trial of Next Level Coaching from Holman Brothers.
From lost opportunities to missed recruiting goals, membership salespeople need expert coaching to push through and achieve. It’s how top performers get ahead and stay there. With next level coaching the Holman Brothers become your membership reps de facto sales trainer, advisor, sounding board, and mentor all rolled into one. Visit holmanbros.com/nextlevel to learn more and request a FREE trial of Next Level Coaching for your membership pro.
Have you considered the many benefits of hosting a podcast for your Chamber? The options, leverage, and possibilities that a podcast offers are virtually endless. Download my FREE Chamber Podcasting Guide to learn how to start your own Chamber podcast!
Below is an auto-generated transcription of my conversation with Richard Scully. Because this is auto-generated there are likely some grammatical errors but it is still a useful tool to search text within this podcast episode.
Feel free to join our Chamber Chat Champions Facebook Group to discuss this episode and to share your own experiences and tips with other Chamber Champions.
Brandon Burton 0:00 This is the Chamber Chat Podcast, the show dedicated to chamber professionals to spark ideas and to get actionable tips and strategies to better serve your members and community.
Voiceover Talent 0:14 And now, your host he wonders what local chambers can do to help resolve the national supply chain issues.
He’s my dad Brandon Burton.
Brandon Burton 0:24 Hello, Chamber Champions. Welcome to Chamber Chat Podcast. I’m your host, Brandon Burton, and it is my goal to introduce you to people and ideas to better help you serve your Chamber members and your community.
Kris Johnson 0:50 Well, Doug and Bill at the Holman Brothers have been a key ally in growth for my professional career working at three different chambers, a local chamber, a regional chamber and now a statewide chamber. And they’ve been the ideal solution, whether it’s a comprehensive training program, whether it’s working on individual sales growth, quarterly check ins with the team, the ability to grow members has meaning more assets for the organization, more assets means we can do more things to serve our members. They’ve really been the perfect solution for us, a trusted resource partner and a growth partner for us all along the way. So hats off to Doug and Bill for their great success. They’ll be a great partner for you as they are for us.
Brandon Burton 1:31 You can learn more about Holman Brothers Membership Sales Solutions by visiting HolmanBros.com.
Doug & Bill Holman know how to diagnose and solve member recruiting issues faster and better than anyone else, and they want to put that knowledge to work for you and your chamber. Learn more at HolmanBros.com.
Guest Introduction
Our guest for this episode is Richard Scully, Richard is CEO and founder of Chamber Nation. Richard has a rich and extensive background in Process automation with many years in corporate infrastructure design, automation, and community advertising networks. His vast experience prepared him to successfully build Chamber Nation from the ground up. Chamber Nation is a national organization with projects in 40 States and Europe. That company uses innovative technology to provide chambers of commerce, merchants, groups and other business organizations to automate their workflow and economic processes. Chamber nation has received two Business of the Year awards, and has had a significant impact on chambers of commerce across the country. Richard contributes his expertise and time by working with Chambers of Commerce executives to better serve their members while working to increase membership. That sounds a lot like my goal here on the podcast, which is why we align so well. But Richard, I’m glad to have you with me today on Chamber Chat Podcast. If you would take a moment to say hello to all the Chamber Champions and share something interesting about yourself so you can get to know you a little better. All right,
Something Interesting About Richard
Richard Scully 2:51 well, hello, everybody. And thank you for this opportunity. Brandon really appreciate it. It’s been a long a long hall building Chamber Nation. It started out where I was CEO, founder of a company called tricep hiring systems that was built at 5 million in sales in Silicon Valley. And during the internet craze, I had Porsches and Mercedes drive up to my office and saw these highfalutin people come in and say Hey, Mr. Skelly, you know like your company. We want to buy your company and I was going wow. And they’re telling me enough, give me a stock. You know, you’re going to be a multi gazillionaire and be able to walk on the beach, the rest of your life and all those kinds of things and, you know, not traditionally used to that kind of environment. I unfortunately fell for it for almost all stock shortly thereafter, within a year actually I lost everything and going from the top after 10 years of building a company that serves some major corporations like KLA 10 core into it. Symantec Eunice’s, it was basically all gone and stock was gone. And I got very little cash up front. So I was in a situation where I still had to work and the dreams are over. So I called my father up in Northern California, I was in Silicon Valley. So my house went to Northern California, and I put my tool belt back on and I was helping him finish up a spec house and he intended to do that kind of work now and it was a shocker. You know, you go from the car in the suit and you know, the business meetings to you know, out in the cold or out in the heat and building a house with a tool belt on is pretty pretty different. So I was I tried to keep my head up but honestly I was you know, inside it, it hurt a lot to lose everything. So I was working out there and somehow Kainoa HF radio it’s a small little Christian radio station. We had a blare on on the boombox. Imagine that and Ron Trumbo, the the person that hung the station was interviewing a guy by the name of Paul Macbeth. And he was the chief for the executive director of the Quincy, California Chamber of Commerce. And I was listening to him and, and he started talking about what they did on a $26,000 year budget. And I was always programmed to look for a business model that appear to need some help, and then build an infrastructure to help that industry. And then hopefully people like it enough to buy it. And then you can build a company. So I had he had offered his cell phone number at the end of the interview, I got out my contractor pencil, I wrote it on a board. And I called him and I literally had lunch the very next day with him it morning thunder and Quincy, I remember this. And he was the nicest guy, he was a former manager of a Safeway store, very successful in Safeway did a lot of different things. And he just a terrific guy. And he’s very supportive. He understood what I’ve gone through. And he just started digging really deep. And I had asked him if I could work in his chamber, or just sit in his chamber and kind of listen to what what goes on in the chamber. He said, Sure, come on down. So it evolved from there ended up building an initial infrastructure, a very lightweight, one cobbled it up, basically just a wireframe to see if this is kind of with this help them and I went from there. And about two months into working on that, him and his wife asked me over for dinner, handed me a $50,000 check. And these weren’t wealthy people, either. This was out of their retirement. And they said, We trust you. And unfortunately, Paul passed away a few years ago, but his wife is still with the company. And we’re very good friends. And she’s always been very supportive. And so has Paul. So that’s how it got started, went to the top went to the bottom and been trying to crawl out of that ever since.
Brandon Burton 7:07 Yeah. Well, that is a good background there of how you how you got into this. Yeah. Why don’t you spend a couple minutes and let us all know a little bit about Chamber Nation, kind of the, the size of the company, the services you offer. Obviously, you work with chambers of commerce, but just dive into that for a little bit before we get into our topic.
About Chamber Nation
Richard Scully 7:30 Sure. So Chamber Nation is we serve hundreds of chambers throughout the country. And also we were invited into Europe. And so we serve Europe and also have installations in Canada, we are really focused on the chamber industry, we, for obvious reasons, you can see how was started. I work in the Support Center. Every day, I’m in the middle of support, I feel like I need to be there because that’s how I understand what is working, what is not working. So I can make adjustments because our mission is obviously to help everyone as much as we possibly can. And you know, we’re we’re listening or so I think the first thing is human nation is very much listening. We’re two platforms, one, not going to focus on the membership management side, but we have very robust management system. But we learned about seven, eight years ago, that there needed to be a change, because in my mind, the chambers of commerce have always been they’ve been out for over 400 years. And they’ve always been the publishing platform for a community. Of course, that was very different in the very early days, like a flea market, you know, providing scales and things to do trade. And then as you move up the United States, the concept of travelers going into a chamber lobby. Well, prior to that, you know, postcards and telephone calls and things like that, and then going to the Chamber of driving to the chamber lobby, asking for brochures, maps, and then we have the internet, you have Google and you have Bing. And honestly, I was at a conference that I ACC conference a number of years ago. And it had a pretty dramatic effect on me because I was listening to a breakout session. And I heard chamber executives saying, Oh, they just go to Google and Bing. And I just go, Oh my gosh, why don’t do that. Don’t do that. And I was thinking in my mind that you know, that’s true. But the fact of the matter is that you know it, it’s not there. I mean, they might think it’s there, but it’s not there. And I just knew that because I had a problem inside of gym relation. As a CEO. I was pretty upset because we had built a lot of very robust membership tools and I, honestly the usage rate was not good. It was terrible. It’s called member engagement. That’s what everybody seems to talk about. And there wasn’t anything that I could do to move to seemingly move the needle and get membership engagement and, you know, improve that, you know, the management systems was clicking away and doing its thing. And it wasn’t, that wasn’t the problem. It was really everything built inside there. For the member side, that was the biggest problem. So I, I realized that, that Google and Bing really didn’t even have the information that the Chamber executives were saying this about just they just go there. So I’m having an issue of member engagement, I was really trying hard to figure out how in the world to change this. And it seems like, if you put a 12 inch by 12 inch login button, on the screen of your chamber website, it would make a difference. So I had an idea, an idea was to go to ACC for three days, take a clipboard and walk around. Some of you might remember me walk around for three days, when I asked the question, may I ask, What technology do you use for your members? I said it in some kind of way. I don’t know if I said management system or membership system, or whatever it was. But anyway, irregardless of what the system was, that was Chamber Nation. Or if it was the latest and greatest mobile app from Silicon Valley, or some other management system, it didn’t matter, every one of us had the same answer, the result was 90% of the members don’t log in, and when they do, they might contribute a paragraph of inflammation. Well, when I left that conference, I was a static, I was so happy because I realized it wasn’t us failing and how we develop it was simply just a, just a general problem. So anyway, when I got on that plane had a clear sheet of paper. And I said, Okay, we’re going to rebuild everything from the ground up, and we got to figure out what we got to do. So one of the things I realized is that the one thing I know for sure is that chambers don’t have a lot of money. So whatever it was that we develop, it had to be very, very inexpensive, and had to be something that could be easily included in the membership plans, because chambers, they don’t want their members upsold. They really, they really don’t like that. So we developed the first of its kind membership services department, we have over 20 people in that department. Now it’s shared across the country by multiple chambers. So we have a full membership services department, I like to explain it this way, that there’s three words and Chamber of Commerce, you have the chamber, and you have commerce. So the idea being in building this is that our customers would continue to handle the chamber like they always do. I mean, we would never suggest telling them how to run their chamber. But we are going to run commerce. And so if we run commerce, and they run the chamber as a team, we can deliver some really amazing results to the members. And that’s what we, that’s what we built. And then one thing led to the next. That was the concept now we needed to create infrastructure to support that at a very low price point, we needed a lot of leverage to make this thing work. And I also didn’t want to make any mistakes. So I started what was called the chamber collaborative, I invited customers to participate, got feedback from a lot of chamber executives on a constant basis. I was very open and honest with him, I would call many of them and say this is what we’re thinking how we’re gonna roll this out, what do you think? Do we need to make any adjustments. And so it really was built from the ground up to serve the Chamber of Commerce Industry. Our whole objective in all of this was to build something to where even if the member wasn’t engaged in membership, that they would get a value back and writing on a monthly basis. So they would wonder at the end of the year, you know, should I renew? I got this report, my numbers are going up every month I’m I think I better really so the whole idea was really changed things around. So Chamber Nation has two systems in one a membership management system membership development system, and when they work hand in hand, it does some amazing things for the community and the chamber and most importantly the member.
Brandon Burton 14:48 Very good. So that does give some really good background about services he offer and how you guys came to be. And it’s always neat to see how people land in the chamber world in general, but then developing tools around that. It’s great to hear that origin story. But you alluded to what our topic for discussion is today, which is going to be membership management versus development. And we’ll jump into that discussion as soon as we get back from this quick break.
Are you looking for a year round affordable and timely shop local campaign for your chamber or CVB Look no further build a custom each shop play mobile app with App My Community by visiting appmycommunity.com/chamberchat. App My Community mobile apps are not just simple membership directory listings. They provide many more capabilities to engage with your community. Provide your residents with a robust events calendar partner with a local fare festival or Farmers Market provide a schedule map and other resources to promote the event. Run a Small Business Saturday campaign any time of the year using built in scavenger hunts allow your membership to communicate directly to their customers via push notifications. Your app my community mobile app will be a unique member benefit allow you to generate non dues revenue with sponsorship opportunities and best of all provide a valuable resource to your community please visit appmycommunity.com/chamberchat now to receive 10% off your first year of an App My Community mobile app.
App My Community creates mobile apps that allow you to engage directly with your community. Enhance chamber membership by providing a unique advertising and communication channel to residents and visitors. Not just a member directory, App My Community has the tools to be useful to residents on a daily basis. Learn more at appmycommunity.com/chamberchat.
Oftentimes Chamber Nation’s customers agree that since Amazon is all centralized then why not their own community including their professional service providers.
Since Chamber Nation includes a full-service membership services department to handle all of the new member onboarding and ongoing support at no extra cost to the Members, this is now possible.
Once the program is all set up, each member going forward will receive monthly membership ROI reports. The entire community will also have access to community-wide economic development reports that are terrific for supporting grant opportunities too.
With Chamber Nation not only will you have a membership management system but also a membership development system all in one terrific package. So, SAVE MONEY and be impressed by visiting www.RichardsCalendar.com to set up a demo with their CEO. Or learn more at www.ChamberNation.com.
Topic-Membership Management vs. Membership Development
All right, Richard, we’re back. As I mentioned before the break, we’re focusing our topic today on membership management versus membership development. So as we look at those two different areas, how do you see that? How do you see management versus development? What’s the difference?
Richard Scully 17:48 Management is operating the chamber. And membership development is operating the commerce. And you really have to have two separate teams focused on each side of that equation. The membership management system obviously needs to be able to send information to the membership development system, you have new members. So when you have new members, it has to notify the commerce side that there’s a new member and a lot of things need to be done. So the management system is supporting the membership development system. And then when the membership development system receives its instructions, and things are done, then it sends notification back to the management system where the chamber lives, the Chamber staff lives and lets them know that this has been completed and this member is ready to be introduced to their new platform. And you know, all of those things occur. And it’s basically a way for the chamber to review everything that’s been done for the member and then they click another button to send out a notification to the member letting them know the chamber has completed their onboarding and click here to look at everything. Click here to work with your member assistant. All that type of thing has to happen between both systems talking. The objective really is so that the membership management system now has a tool that will communicate with members on a regular basis letting them know exactly how well the chamber has been able to promote their business. tracking things from telephone referrals to electronic requests for additional information. You have your reports that run on a monthly basis that come from the chamber to the member letting them know this is what we’ve done providing them reminders. This is how you log in with idea being that they’re much more inclined to engage when they start receiving reports, every month that something significant has been happening in on behalf of their business, and they get curious. So it’s really helped from the engagement point of view, but membership development is really the handle everything. Commerce related. Oh, yeah.
Brandon Burton 20:24 I was just gonna ask from maybe from that point of view, or bridging that gap from the management to development? What is the the training like with the onboarding of a new member to say, here’s how our system works, you’ll enter some information here, what does it chamber need to do on the front end versus when the system takes over and kind of sends those reports and keeps the engagement level up? What’s that, that bridge like?
Richard Scully 20:51 Well, that we look at that as our responsibility, we as a company, we have to deal with that. So one of the things that is very important in the whole process is that we do all of the research on the businesses, and we do all the development, all the membership profile pages, because although we’re our objective is to pivot a Chamber’s traditional membership directory, into a full blown publishing platform. It’s, it’s, it’s really important that you know that the work for the members are actually being done. So we do all the research, all the development, all the build out, you know, the catalogs or mobile applications or texting platforms, you know, all kinds of things or customer testimonial systems, their coupon management, which actually generates coupon booklet. So, we know that electronic coupons are cool, but they’re not used a lot. So what we’ve done is we developed that to where it goes from electronic to print automatically through our community coupon booklet, so that chambers have a tangible something to show and say, Listen, when you go when you do this, it’s not only going on the website, on your mobile app, and in your catalog, but it’s also going to the community coupon book, like another reason that we can kind of motivate them if you will, to get logged in. So they answer your question, we do that onboarding, research, onboarding, we provide all of the support unlimited at no charge to the members, so that it’s very easy to get support. But when they get these monthly reports, to show them exactly what is happening there, they’re motivated to get in and take a look. And we’ve just added the ability now for them to add video profiles. And all of this is designed so when they look at the dashboard, and they click on it, it’s just real self explanatory. We’ve been building a lot of technology for a number of years. And now we’re going to pull that back because we have so much. And we’re just going to focus on improving our training, we have a woman Her name is Rachel, she works at the full Shar Katie, Chamber of Commerce in Texas, she is going to be starting our new monthly zoom member and training. In she’ll be talking about that specifically from the point of view of the chamber, where they do a lot of classes. Now, you know, real estate agents use it differently than mortgage brokers and retailers. And that’s another thing with with the platform, when you’re building a marketplace for a chamber, it can’t be a store. And everything out there that sold is a store and the reason it can’t be a stores because I don’t think you’re going to find one attorney or one, you know, one real estate agent, nobody like that insurance is going to want to have a store with a checkout, you know, on it that does just doesn’t fit. So we had to build this to accommodate the 80%, which are service providers, and then the 20%, which are retailers with one switch, they can switch it into a complete commission free ecommerce platform. So another benefit of being a chamber member is that you get access to all these tools. So self explanatory, easy to use, all the setup being done is is critical for a successful platform. And I mean, even in the very beginning, you know, one of the stumbling blocks we had was, you know, calling the members to learn more about their business and we realize that people don’t answer their phones anymore. It’s almost impossible. So this has been a really hard model to figure out is it’s taken a long time, a lot of technology. We’re making slight adjustments all the time and the technology to make it smoother and smoother. But fortunately for our customers they don’t see See that part of it because we really are handling the commerce side. And although they have access to the commerce platform or the membership development platform, that’s really for us to use, but they have unencumbered access to be able to get into every business and to see all the stats and exactly what’s happening on the Commerce front. And we also have like for chambers that are going out for grants, we have community wide economic development reporting. And that’s really helpful because they can now generate reports on a community wide level, to help justify any grants that they get for, you know, their visitor centers or economic development, all kinds of different things. And we have several chambers that have actually no one grants.
Brandon Burton 25:48 That’s awesome. So there’s a couple of thoughts that came to mind as you were given this explanation of kind of how the software works in the hole bridging that gap. You had mentioned about roughly 80% of Chamber members tend to be more of the service providers and the other 20%, kind of the the retail shops and things of that nature. And you had mentioned, the ability to set up a an E commerce shop. So I know I’ve talked about this, especially through the pandemic, for those that had retail shops that didn’t really have a strong online presence, the important for chambers to kind of be that catalyst to help those businesses get their brick and mortar online. And the potential of selling out the back door more or less. Can you touch a little bit more on what that’s like for trying to get some of these brick and mortar retail shops online with the retail store and ecommerce platform.
Richard Scully 26:49 None of it is easy. I mean, first of all, most people are our most retailers are slanted towards not selling online, one of the things that we learned is that they have a real problem managing inventory, because they have a physical store, they have an electronic store. And if they run out of stock, then and someone buys it online, or they don’t go and take it down, which a lot of them don’t do, then you have a problem. So they shy away from that. One of the things that has helped though, is that what we’ve done is we’ve decoupled the merchant account, there is an ability to use PayPal, but we suggest that they don’t do it that way. And they use our integrated checkout request system. This way, when a retailer has products that they also sell in their store, when somebody purchases that product, it will send an order request receipt to the buyer. And it sends an order request to the member so that the member can now check inventory, and then complete the checkout on whatever terminal they currently use. Which makes it really, really easy because remember, we’re not in the middle of the transaction, charging a commission, we’re not interested in charging anything. This is a this is a member service, it’s included in membership, there’s no upselling. So it’s a very legitimate transaction. So since we don’t have to take a piece of it, then we can decouple the merchant account. And that works great. We also have inventory in the online version where they can put in like they could have 20 available in there and automatically click down until it goes to zero. And then what it does is instead of deleting the item, it puts it in hides it and puts it in the warehouse so to speak. So later on, you can unhide it, bring it back and put inventory levels back in. But it’s a simple in our platform, every every every catalog is full of what we call displays. And they are cataloged displays, because you know, your professional services, you know, catalog display as a store is is the appropriate nomenclature, I guess you would say. And all all a member has to do is begin to take when they open up those displays, they add more displays, they just simply put in a price and when they add the price, the whole infrastructure changes into a store. So and you know we like to say that Amazon is all centralized. So why not your own chamber community including the internet, including the professional service providers, and that’s exactly what’s happening because the Chamber’s always been the central hub of everything. And unless, you know if they don’t take the electronic side of things really seriously, then they’re really going to lose out and you know, it’s not something to celebrate, but in most communities today, local newspapers, you know, the subscriber levels are down and that’s not a good thing. I like traditional media. Local radio same kind of thing. I mean, look, podcasts are competitors to radio now a lot of different things. So I’m, we’re really positioning the Chamber of Commerce now to become the default advertising hub for each and every community across the country. And it works because we’re doing the work. And if you just put in technology, and I know this, because I asked a lot of questions, and it didn’t matter. You know what technology it was, the vast majority of people just don’t log in to anything. So you’ve got it, you’ve got to, you’ve got to deal with that. And that’s, it’s taken us many years and too much money to build everything from scratch all over again. But, you know, that’s what we had to do. And if I didn’t go to that ACC conference, you know, I would have never would have never understood the problem.
Brandon Burton 30:56 So that kind of hits on the other point that I wanted to bring up. As I’ve mentioned in a couple podcast episodes in the past, where I like to encourage chambers occasionally to do what I call the yellow highlighter exercise, where you look at your own membership list and take out the highlighter and markup, you know, all the members that have any level of engagement with the chamber. And oftentimes, chambers are no surprises the right word, but when you see it in front of you with the how low of a percentage of engagement for on any level, whether opening emails, responding on social media, attending a luncheon, whatever it may be, just to kind of have that pulse. And I do it from the perspective of, you know, for chambers doing their own podcast, it’s just another way to engage their membership. But what I like about what you’re, what you’re talking about here with the this platform, is it offers another way, and kind of reminders even for these members to be engaged, to be found easier online to allow the chamber to be a better advocate for their business, you know, based on their engagement. So I’m going to guess that your customers probably don’t need to pull out a yellow highlighter, you probably have a report, it’ll spit out whatever membership engagement level their members have. But I think that’s important for for chambers all over to look at what that engagement levels like further.
Richard Scully 32:25 Yeah, and you and you almost have to force it. You have to force a level of engagement in order to get them engaged. And I really believe in that. I mean, I had a you know, it’s it’s, it’s one of those things just recently, I was invited to come two days to Green Valley, Arizona, Green Valley, Sarita chamber, and they had some formal chamber member workshops there and, and they had me down and it was quite nice. And it was interesting, because, you know, the members are saying, holy cow, I never had any idea that the chamber was doing any of this, you know, and you’re overwhelmed with questions. And oh, it does that too. And they’re very excited because the chamber typically ranks pretty doggone high on search engines, they do really well with their websites. The directories do well, too. They do they do phenomenally well. It’s amazing. But people really do still use the chamber member directories. And I think it’s because it’s a dedicated local directory, unlike Google and Bing, where you’re going to get local results, but you’re not going to get something that’s like local, local, local, right. So people realize that, oh, when I’m connecting the chamber, I get all of that attention online. I’m getting backlinks from here, I’m getting backlinks from the director of getting backlinks from a catalog, my mobile app, I’m getting, you know, all these different things happening, that are helping to promote their business. A lot of people think of it as SEO, I don’t use that word very much. I like to think that if it’s on the internet, it’s going to be found. But if it’s not on the internet, it’s not. And in most cases, the businesses do not document their products and services at all. So it’s not even there to be found in the first place on Google and Bing. So. And when we add a new business, we’re adding about 10 to 12 additional pages onto the internet for each business, just as a starter point after that they can get into hundreds of pages if they’d like. So I think the the engagement is you’ve got to work to engage that member through a success story. And then when they see oh, wow, this thing seems to be working. They’re much easier to talk to about engagement. I know this because going to workshops, not only Green Valley, but others I was also in Texas, to where, you know, the members are like going, Wow, this is this is fantastic. And they have a new appreciation for the chamber, they realize that the Chamber has grown up and you know is with it and understands technology and understand support. And you know, that’s how that’s how you get it, how you get engagement moving, in my opinion, because that’s how we been able to get it moving.
Brandon Burton 35:28 That’s right. I know, we need to start wrapping up here. But I did want to ask you, if you might have one tip or action item that a chamber champion listening to do to maybe help lift their chamber up to the next level? Yeah,
Action Item/Tip for Chamber Champions
Richard Scully 35:44 I had an experience many years ago, some of you may be too young to remember this company. But most of you probably will, it was called Kinkos. And I believe it’s a FedEx thinner now, and I was traveling a lot trying to build trying to build try step, the company I mentioned before, and I had a proposal that was do very, very important. It was a multi million dollar potential contract, and I ran into some problems on my computer. And I remember going into Kinkos, and the woman sat me down at a computer. And she showed me all these graphics files that were already pre installed. And I mean, they just treated me like the king. And I’ll never forget it. And I’ve always thought about, you know, the chamber, converting chambers into these little Kinkos support centers where when you walked into the chamber, because you’re trying to help grow your business, that they really are a one stop shop for helping you be successful. And I think there’s a lot of chambers that do things a lot a lot differently, but they offer great solutions the way they are. But being able to say listen, you know, the chamber is a one stop shop for everything to promote your business, I think is a is my suggestion.
Brandon Burton 37:04 All right. Appreciate that. So I’d like to ask everybody, as we look to the future of chambers, how do you see the future of chambers and their purpose going forward?
Future of Chambers
Richard Scully 37:15 I, I see Chambers as the digital platform. I see the chamber as the attention grabber from the internet to disperse, leads and prospects to its local business community. I see the chamber as the legislative action center, an organization that that surfaces the important local topics that local businesses need to know about. And I see them as an extraordinarily valuable digital hub of the future. That’s how I see it. I mean, some people might think I’m wack. But, you know, I really believe that so many things are moving to the digital side, that somebody in a community is got to be a custodian of local information. And the chamber has always been there for that. And I just believe that they should be there during this digital transformation that we’re just beginning when I mean, you know, we’re already thinking about Metaverse, right? We’re already thinking about how do you do crypto in a community? I mean, there’s all kinds of opportunities that are coming up ahead that that somebody is going to have to be the custodian. The trusted source of local information, as I call it, is the chamber so I see it as the digital connection tool the future.
Brandon Burton 38:45 I love that answer. And then the nice thing about looking at the future is nobody can ever say you’re wrong because there’s always a future. The first Richard, I appreciate you spending time with us today on Chamber Chat Podcast I did I wanted to give you an opportunity to put out any contact information for anyone listening who want to get in contact with you and maybe further explore some of these ideas that you shared and services Chamber Nation has to offer.
Connect with Richard Scully
Richard Scully 39:14 Yeah, thank you, Brandon. So email address. Well, first of all, ChamberNation.com is where you can find us. I always ask people to go to RichardsCalendar.com to find a time that might work for you for a meeting or you can call me just click the sales department option but it’s 855-Add-Members that’s our phone number 855-Add-Members and just click the sales department option and you’ll get me that there too.
Brandon Burton 39:48 All right, we will get this in our show notes for this episode should be found at chamberchatpodcast.com/episode161 but Richard this has been a fun conversation and hopefully one that kind of expands the thoughts and visions of those Chamber Champions that are out there listening. So thank you for joining me today.
Richard Scully 40:07 Thank you man. Appreciate it very much.
Brandon Burton 40:09 If you are a chamber professional, please subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast in Apple podcast, Google podcasts or Spotify. When you subscribe to Chamber Chat Podcast new episodes will show up in your podcast app each week as they are released. If you’re finding value in this podcast, please leave us a rating and a review in iTunes. But most importantly, please share Chamber Chat Podcast with your colleagues that are in the industry.
Click here for a FREE trial of Next Level Coaching from Holman Brothers.
When chamber leaders talk about sales training, they tend to describe membership knowledge of course, knowing how membership works is important. However, knowing how to sell memberships is essential. Holman Brothers Next Level Coaching offers a unique balance of year round membership sales coaching and mentoring to deliver the support your membership rep needs to consistently produce for your chamber.
Successful membership salespeople are problem solvers. They ask better questions, uncover more problems and pinpoint how their Chamber can help. It’s how they consistently drive better membership sales outcomes. Here’s the hurdle, most membership salespeople don’t get enough coaching to recruit like this. Holman Brothers Next Level Coaching supplies the year round guidance at your membership rep needs to drive growth for your chamber. Visit holmanbros.com/nextlevel to learn more and request a free trial of Next Level Coaching.
Have you considered the many benefits of hosting a podcast for your Chamber? The options, leverage, and possibilities that a podcast offers are virtually endless. Download my FREE Chamber Podcasting Guide to learn how to start your own Chamber podcast!
Chambers of Commerce have promoted networking opportunities as a key selling proposition to prospective members for decades. Many businesses are sold on the idea of networking events creating leads which will sustain their business.
What typically happens, and you can ask your members, is everyone comes for the happy hour drinks, and they bring their business cards, and they are super uncomfortable. They might stay for a little while with the hopes that the evening will take a turn for the better but ultimately end up leaving early. Oftentimes, they feel as if they were a target for other networkers to try to sell them the whole time. I know this is the case because I hear it from Chamber members everywhere I go. These members are so uncomfortable and disappointed with their lack of real connections made from these networking events that they stop attending all together. Once this happens, then one of the big outward facing benefits that your Chamber provides is no longer of value to these types of members.
As I meet with member businesses as I sell advertising for Chamber publications, I often joke that I feel like a bartender…everyone is very open to share their experiences with me (good or bad) about their Chamber. These discussions are very insightful and they have no idea that I host an industry wide podcast or that I write this blog, but their honesty is very revealing.
Directories, magazines, maps, and digital… Consider Community Matters, Inc. for your next chamber publication.
Your Impact is Much Greater than Networking
Before I go any deeper into increasing the quality of your networking events, I want to make mention that I am a big believer in the positive work that Chambers do to strengthen and develop their communities. I believe that networking is often done because this offering is the easiest to explain to a business owner the value that the Chamber can provide for their business. It is a starting point!
If you can create a high quality first experience for your members, then it will be much easier for them to understand your greater mission. You will be much more successful at having your members catch your Chamber’s vision and join in with your cause.
Has your Chamber participated in leadership trips? Think of the connectivity that is created with group travel. You want to try to stimulate these connections among your members too.
So, how do you create a great first experience with networking for your members?
It Starts with an Invitation
I recently read a book by Jon Levy called “You’re Invited: The Art and Science of Creating Influence”. In the book, Jon explains that for years he has hosted very exclusive dinner events. He invites people from all walks of life, who have never met each other to his home. His guests only use their first names as they converse with each other. They also prepare the meal, eat, and wash the dishes together. At the end of the evening as these groups of individuals have created and shared a meal with each other, and shared laughs and stories, they then go around the room and share their last name and who they are.
Jon has had olympic athletes, scientists, authors, garbage collectors, doctors, celebrities, coaches, influencers, and some of the biggest names in society as guests of his dinner parties. Once the true identities are shared, shock fills the room as the other guests learn who they have been sharing their evening and experiences with.
Jon has created an alumni group of all of his past dinner guests and he still brings them together and has built a rather large following with one invitation and one dinner party at a time.
Marjorie Hinkley shared a great thought “There isn’t a person you wouldn’t love if you could read their whole story.” I think this quote resonates well with the idea of truely getting to know a person before casting judgments or trying to sell them your products or services.
Imagine Your Networking Event
I believe that Chamber networking events could be done much better with more intentionality. I will share a thought of how this might look…
You could start by identifying a segment of your membership to focus on for a specific event. This could be those who are connected to the real estate industry, or hospitality, or tourism, or retail.
You look through your membership list and find some options for activities that this segment of members could participate in together. For example, painting at a board and brush member business or being taught by a chef at a local restaurant how to cook the perfect steak. You can and should get very creative with the event ideas.
Set some rules for the event to make it more into a game. It may seem counterintuitive, but one rule might be that you are not allowed to talk about your business for the first 30 minutes or hour. This will create some tension but it will also allow for the attendees to fully engage without the fear of becoming a target.
Create and send out physical invitations that create a little bit of mystery which will insight curiosity.
Assuming that the event goes well, you could solicit feedback and suggestions from your guests for future events for guests from other segments of your membership.
You could take this to another level by capturing some of these positive outcomes and testimonials that come as a result of your event to show how creative your Chamber is. This will show how much you really do care about being a convener of leaders and influencers in your community.
Boost your Chamber’s efficiency & revenues with digital certification of origin and movement documents, powered by essCert – the leading choice for 400 Chambers & 50,000+ satisfied Chamber members.
Consider Diversity in your Segmentations
As you look forward to future events, I would encourage you to think out of the box when it comes to the segments of your membership. With diversity, equity, and inclusion being top of mind for so many, it would do your Chamber well to purposely think about who is not being represented. Most Chambers do well with segmenting and focusing on women owned businesses and young entrepreneurs. You could host an event for veteran owned businesses or black owned businesses. The key is to get the right people into the right room, while creating an experience that builds relationships beyond the superficial business card exchange.
Nobody likes to be sold to, but everyone appreciates being noticed.
Stronger Relationships Create Greater Purpose
I have a theory that has me believe that if you can create a high-quality early impression for new Chamber members, they will be more willing to hear what else you have to offer to support their business. This in turn will lead to higher membership retention and overall growth and these business owners tell others how great your Chamber is and why they need to join.
Just today, I had a Chamber member who is also an ambassador tell me that she invited one of her business neighbors to the Chamber’s annual banquet. The neighbor told her that they were not Chamber members so she replied by saying “Well, then you need to join. It is the right thing to do.” This Chamber ambassador then confided in me that she was so disappointed that she didn’t have any better reason to give this other business to join the Chamber other than it is the right thing to do.
Flex Your Influencer Muscle
Many of your members may not be completely convinced about why they are a member of your organization or how long they will continue to be a member. Once you can give them a solid, compelling, great experience, they will never have to question what they get from your Chamber ever again. They will also become an advocate for your organization if you create a believer out of these members early on.
We all understand the great power that comes with a group of like minded individuals who get behind a cause. Before a person can fully support a cause and join a group, they need to have a strong enough why. Chamber networking events are the visible, outward facing membership offering that most people can relate with. Now we just need to use a powerful enough hook to help them catch the Chamber fever.
What creative networking events have you tried? I would love to hear what you are doing and what works. You can email me at brandon@chamberchatpodcast.com to tell me your stories.
Please join our email list to receive new blog posts are they are released. You will stay in the loop with any announcements related to the podcast or the Chamber world in general.
Also, be sure you are subscribed to Chamber Chat Podcast in your favorite podcast app. Subscribers are the first to get episodes as new ones come out each week.